# News: Jamie Dimon attacks corporate DEI — is he right?

- **Episode:** [180](https://agents.truthliesandwork.com/episodes/180.md) (2025-03-18)
- **Type:** news-roundup
- **Tags:** dei, corporate-policy, leadership
- **Time:** 13:23–20:25 (start 803s)
- **Listen:** [https://truthliesandwork.com/180?t=803](https://truthliesandwork.com/180?t=803)

---

[13:23] Leanne Elliott: Yes, I have to ask you, Al, are diversity policies hurting companies?
[13:28] Al Elliott: Oof, this is a thorny one. I mean, the thing is, what's difficult is that I have edited this afternoon Sarah Gashier's Our Hot Take. So I have a little bit of an inkling to this, but I'm gonna pretend I didn't. So, I don't know, how can they possibly hurt companies?
[13:41] Leanne Elliott: Well, that was a great example of boomer asking. Jamie Dimon, CEO of JPMorgan, is back in the news again. He's the kiss of death. Making headlines. He really, honestly, there was about 3 stories from him that I had to choose from, but I think this fitted in well with our hot take as well. So what is Jamie doing this time? Well, this time he's taking direct aim at 2 of the world's most influential advisory firms, and his main criticism is that their aggressive push for corporate diversity, equality, and inclusion policies isn't good. According to Dimon, these advisors are creating such a heavy regulatory burden that companies are actually choosing to exit public markets. In other words, he believes their influence is making corporate governance overly complicated, expensive, And ultimately harmful. Dimon didn't hold back, as we know he doesn't. Speaking at BlackRock's Retirement Summit, he labelled the 2 proxy advisors, which are Glass Lewis and Institutional Shareholder Services, or ISS, as incompetent, suggesting they should be gone, dead, done with
[14:51] Al Elliott: Quite the dramatist, isn't he?
[14:54] Leanne Elliott: Very dramatic. He even went further, saying that anyone who pays these firms for advice should be ashamed of themselves. Why does it matter? Well, these 2 advisory firms are hugely influential. They advise around 90% of the world's largest pension funds and asset managers. They're basically shaping how big investors vote on critical company issues like who sits on boards, how executives get paid, and increasingly how companies handle diversity and social responsibility. Now, Dimon's criticism, criticism isn't happening in isolation. There are currently wider backlash, particularly in the US, against what some are calling woke capitalism. Donald Trump— I got him in, I'm not usually allowed to talk about DT— Donald Trump notably has led a movement against DEI initiatives, prompting giants like Google, Amazon, and Meta to roll back long-standing diversity fallacies. Fallacies? Policies
[15:49] Al Elliott: Fallacies, a phallus. Yes, carry on
[15:52] Leanne Elliott: Policies. In fact, these proxy advisors themselves, um, have also started to shift position. I can't imagine why. Following Trump's electoral victory— that's why— ISS announced it would stop explicitly considering gender, ethnic, or racial diversity when recommending company directors. Meanwhile, Glass Lewis says it's reviewing whether its DEI recommendations are truly aligned with their clients' interests, though it is still including diversity considerations in its advice for now. It is also worth noting this isn't Dimon's first battle with Glass Lewis or ISS. They have previously criticized his own pay package, and last year Glass Lewis famously opposed a $56 billion pay package to Tesla's Elon Musk, labeling it excessive. How they responded— ISS has defended their approach, emphasizing that investors rely on their objective and independent research free from undue interference by company management. Glass Lewis hasn't yet commented publicly. So what do we think? Are diversity and inclusion initiatives genuinely benefiting companies or the employees they're intended to help, or have they become just another layer of corporate complexity?
[17:02] Al Elliott: Firstly, I am not qualified to, to talk about this whatsoever, being a white middle-class male of a certain age. So I certainly am not. Um, I can I can kind of see some of the— I can see the— I can see why some people might say this because they might go, well, you know, people are being promoted to certain positions based on the fact that we need a diversity hire. Well, we need to, you know, even up the number of women on our board, for example, when in actual fact they're not as qualified. I can see that, but I don't understand it well enough to be able to go, oh, well, that's what— this is what needs to happen. I mean, what's your thoughts, Leanne?
[17:38] Leanne Elliott: I'm not sure. Mr. Dimon is really talking about DEI. I think he just wants a pop at some organizations that are making his life a bit harder right now. And I think it's one of those things that's in the news already, it gets picked up, it— you know, I find it hard to feel sorry for these billionaires that are struggling with DEI because why? They think it's taking opportunities away from them? No, I don't think so. I just think it means things are a bit more expensive. They need to pay people fairly. I don't know. I don't think it's about any of that. That said, we do know that some EDI practices aren't particularly effective, and they can unintentionally isolate the groups that they're meant to help. We've seen this famously talked about by Adam Grant in his book Hidden Potential. There's also been studies from Harvard Business Review which does kind of say that, you know, if diversity hires are made, typically those people feel undervalued and isolated. So it's not to say that there isn't research out there that certain diversity measures aren't working. That's very different to saying DEI doesn't work. So I think we need to be very careful in terms of, I guess, throwing the baby out with the bathwater, essentially. That said, as you alluded to, Al, we do have quite an interesting take on this, a hot take on this. Coming up just after the break
[19:03] Al Elliott: Yeah, I think the other thing that, just the last thought on this is not around the actual diversity, DEI, which I've got no business getting involved in, but more like it seems like there's more and more people aligning themselves with this DT guy who's now president. More and more people are just aligning themselves with what he believes. So they're trying to like sort of get in the back door like Musk has, because Musk is obviously having, you know, all his dreams are coming true right now, aren't they? So
[19:29] Leanne Elliott: Did you see that? Sorry to go off topic a minute. The open letter written from Tesla to the US government, basically saying that they think the new tariffs aren't cool and it's going to massively affect the automobile industry
[19:44] Al Elliott: This wasn't from Musk then?
[19:45] Leanne Elliott: Well, it wasn't signed by anyone at Tesla. It was just Tesla, which is interesting because wasn't it when all the Twitter layoffs were happening, it wasn't signed from anybody, it was just signed from Twitter. And previously it was signed by somebody. So to me, Do you know what I mean? It's just, it's just—
[20:03] Al Elliott: You okay?
[20:04] Leanne Elliott: Carry on
[20:05] Al Elliott: Do you wanna cuddle?
[20:06] Leanne Elliott: Please
[20:07] Al Elliott: Got something even better because up next, our hot take is from the expert Sarah Gashier, and she's got some pretty spicy views on DEI as they currently stand. She says they're not working and it's time to rebuild them from scratch. So don't go anywhere. Join us for Sarah Gashier
