# Workplace Surgery: Do I Have to Fake It to Get Promoted?

- **Episode:** [208](https://agents.truthliesandwork.com/episodes/208.md) (2025-06-24)
- **Type:** workplace-surgery
- **Tags:** promotion, career-advice, authenticity, workplace
- **Time:** 41:12–47:30 (start 2472s)
- **Listen:** [https://truthliesandwork.com/208?t=2472](https://truthliesandwork.com/208?t=2472)

---

[41:12] Leanne Elliott: There's a lot of episodes there
[41:14] Al Elliott: There's a lot. There's 200-odd episodes. Yeah, so we get a little drunker on that one. Actually, we don't get drunk at all on this one, just to be clear. Okay. Question number 2. Do I have to fake it to get promoted? I'm 28. I'm project coordination for 4 years, but last week my manager told me I'm not leadership material because I don't speak up enough in meetings or make myself visible. Apparently I need to build influence. The thing is, I listen more than I talk. I avoid drama. I get on with the work and fix things before they become problems. I've tried being louder for a month and it just feels fake and it feels exhausting and I don't think it's working. So here's my question. Do I really need to become someone I'm not to get ahead? I put the wrong intonation on that. Do I need to become someone I'm not to get ahead?
[42:01] Leanne Elliott: No, but you might need to manage the expectations of others and how they see you at work. This is one of the most frustrating myths for me in, in the workplace is that extroverts equal better leaders. The loudest person in the room is often not the smartest. So, I think that is just a myth that isn't— you are actually also really smart though
[42:25] Al Elliott: That's true
[42:26] Leanne Elliott: Every rule needs an exception, doesn't it?
[42:28] Al Elliott: That's true
[42:28] Leanne Elliott: Every rule needs an exception. So, I think, I think, yeah, loudness gets you noticed, um, but being talkative isn't great leadership. Um, that's not really how How it works. And introverts can absolutely lead. We talked to John Amici about this when he was on the show, and he was very, very clear that often introverted leaders can be even more effective because they're more introspective, they're more reflective, they're more empathetic. I think he said something like, you know, no one's ever turned to a leader and gone, you're just too empathetic. It doesn't work like that. So yeah, we just— introverts just lead differently. And that's okay. But of course, because we're in a system that exists already and favors extroverts, we might need to just tweak some of our behaviors occasionally so we get on and get up. So, yes. So, I think you don't have to fake it. And you're right, that will be exhausting because there's all this effort going in, which is hard for an introvert anyway. But anything that is the dissonance between our behavior and how we're actually thinking and feeling inside is going to cause tension
[43:34] Al Elliott: Yeah
[43:34] Leanne Elliott: And ultimately stress. So, I think it's really kind of looking at behaviours that guide your decisions, guide your approach to leadership, and maybe being a bit more vocal about those with your leader. So, say for example, you might go into them and just check in with him. And I used to do this with my manager actually, and it took him a little while to get to know me. Once he did, he'd get to the point where he'd tell me something and go, I'm going to leave that with you, I'll call you in about an hour. I'm like, cool, great. What I'd say is, if you've had a really positive conversation with a member of staff that was maybe a bit difficult. Maybe they had a bit of beef. Maybe they weren't happy with how something was being handled in the organization. Maybe you sat down with them, you had that conversation with empathy, with honesty. You explained the reasoning behind the decision. You gave them the why. They then understood, like, okay, I get it, you've got my buy-in, let's move forward. You might then want to phone your manager and go, just to put it on your radar, nothing to worry about at all, but I've just had a conversation with a member of staff— you don't need to say who— Member of staff who thought this, felt that, had a conversation with them. I brought them around, they're now on board, but I just thought, just wanted to share that, um, with you. It then kind of shows, okay, so the behaviors that, that this person is enacting as a leader that I thought weren't effective actually are, or they're enacting behaviors I didn't even realize they were enacting and are effective. So it's almost like you need to be a bit more vocal in feeding back your approach and how that's working
[44:57] Al Elliott: Yeah
[44:57] Leanne Elliott: And I think this is maybe what, what you'll feel comfortable in terms of speaking up. It isn't being the loudest person in the meetings, but it's maybe speaking up in terms of what's going on in the organization and how you've handled it effectively. So that can be one technique that, that you can do. There's also gonna be lots of organizations out there who are going to appreciate a more introverted leader, who are gonna, um, yeah, look for leaders that have the right behaviors Rather than the right talking voice. We heard that from NHS Christie a few weeks ago. And actually, in terms of that, one thing that may help is understanding the behaviours that you are acting and you are doing effectively, and doing something like a psychometric, like the Real World Leader, could help you do that. So then you can understand your own behaviours better, so you can point them out more effectively to the manager. At this point, there's going to be people going, this sounds like you're just telling him to do his manager's job for him. Yeah, essentially, because your manager doesn't know what she's talking about or he's talking about, because they're making incorrect assumptions about what it is to be an effective leader. So, at this point, you're going to have to try and educate them because it doesn't sound like they can educate themselves
[46:02] Al Elliott: Yeah, and I'd probably maybe suggest, see if there's anyone else on your team who you can sort of team up with. So, maybe the idea being that in meetings, then if you've got like a partner in crime that you've met and deal with, then you could, they can say, oh, did you know that Arthur did this thing? And Arthur and you being Arthur can go, oh yeah, you know, I did do this thing. I'll tell you a bit more about it if you want. Just gives you that in rather than going, yeah, I did this thing, which is quite awkward if you are slightly more introverted or you don't like speaking up quite so much. I think what Leanne says is just be yourself, be authentic. Um, and if, if it might be a bit tough, this, but if, if you're not being, if you're not being appreciated for being yourself in this organization and you're still putting, turning in great work and contributing
[46:43] Leanne Elliott: Yeah
[46:44] Al Elliott: Long-term, it might not be the organisation for you, but obviously don't make any rash decisions. But yeah, the last thing you want to do is fake it, because to be honest, faking it, as Leanne said, takes so much energy from you, but also, also is inauthentic, and people can spot it a mile off
[47:00] Leanne Elliott: I mean, the other thing that you could do is ask some more questions around what your manager said about leadership material. What does leadership material look like in this organisation? What are the behaviours, the values, the outcomes that they drive. It might be that you're doing that, but just in a different way. So again, you're going to have to try and find a way to vocalise that in a way that's effective and comfortable for you, but it might be worth digging into exactly what the leadership material means, so you can have a better understanding of how you can reach that, but in your own unique way
