# What the judges look for and the role of ESG

- **Episode:** [24](https://agents.truthliesandwork.com/episodes/24.md) (2023-01-31)
- **Type:** other
- **Tags:** judging-criteria, esg, wellbeing
- **Time:** 11:32–22:48 (start 692s)
- **Listen:** [https://truthliesandwork.com/24?t=692](https://truthliesandwork.com/24?t=692)

---

[11:32] Leanne Elliott: So clearly a business case there once again for prioritizing Wellbeing and healthy workplaces. Let's hear Donna. So as we said, Donna is Head of Operations and People at Open Credo, who is the winner in the small business category
[11:47] Al Elliott: I think, um, it has made us realise, really realise, the impact of people-focused activities that can have on the workplace itself. Um, and also that a lot of these things, they sort of, they, they almost Not happening in the background, but they're not always in the forefront of people's mind that these things are being put in place, like people, you know, support and various benefits and those sorts of things. And I just think it's brought it much more to the forefront of the importance really of a wide spectrum of people-focused activities. And I'm not talking about just the social things and those, but there's celebrating people's achievements. We do that as well every month. And also, I think there's a focus, and also I think there's a focus on us as individuals, as we've individually answered the survey. Perhaps there's a focus of like, actually, I could do more here for myself as well. So, which is not necessarily what the company can do. So, um, the company can't help me sleep better, but that's something that I can do myself, you know. So it's helpful for those, those aspects as well
[12:51] Leanne Elliott: Donna raised a really good point there, you know. As business leaders, we can't, we can't control every aspect of a person's Wellbeing or, or health, there are certain things that we can do and other things that we can help to, to support them. But I think what's great about what Donna said there is even just making this part of the conversation and raising awareness then helps you feel more, more accountable and more empowered as an individual to start to make some lifestyle changes as well
[13:14] Al Elliott: I think it's really worthwhile because when you examine something, like what gets measured gets managed, when you examine something, it does make you ask questions. Talking of asking questions, let's hear from the researcher
[13:24] Leanne Elliott: Christian
[13:24] Al Elliott: And what I realized is that very few organizations at the time, very few academics are really looking at the human factor. So it's almost like the human factor was taken out of these systems. And we were talking about systems, processes, capacity in abstract terms, and not really thinking about how the human was really at the center of this. And also, sometimes we, I guess, we sort of reduced the human to being sort of this rational being, economic being, And ultimately what we know, Leanne, is that there's many dimensions to human behavior, and there's a very strong, you know, irrational side to it as well, to human behavior and so on. So really understanding really what's, how health and wellbeing of individuals plays into this, I think was really, really quite critical
[14:10] Leanne Elliott: I had a really interesting conversation with Christian, and I think one of the things that I really enjoyed hearing about was Why? Why do we need to examine work behaviors and wellbeing? Here's Kristian
[14:22] Al Elliott: The idea was really to look at certain types of work behaviors and then look at what the health and wellbeing impacts of that work behavior would be. So for instance, you could say sending emails late in the evening is bad for health and wellbeing, or you get up really early and you start working, that is bad for your health and wellbeing, or being in excessive number of meetings during the day might be bad for your health and wellbeing. These were the hypotheses that we were testing. As it happens, in this research, what we showed is that there are really different categories of workers. First of all, that's important to think about. So, you know, even within an organization, there are a variety of different subcultures. And these workers typically like to work in slightly different ways. And that's interesting. And if you dig below that, there is no real uniform type of work behaviors that leads to optimal health and wellbeing outcomes. So what this means is really that there's a high degree of personalization that is required within a workforce. So having a blanket ban on emails after 7 or 8 in the evening might seem like a good idea to a chief executive, but ultimately, you probably are sort of impacting negatively the, you know, a certain group of workers within your organization
[15:37] Leanne Elliott: There's 2 things I took from that. I think the first of, you know, why should we measure these behaviors? Our assumptions can be wrong. You know, Christian here is a very experienced scientist and, and researcher. And as he said there, they had hypotheses that, that turned out not to be true
[15:53] Al Elliott: And I think, and anecdotally, that does make sense because we all know people who, who send emails at 6 in the morning. And, you know, some of them, it just works better for them to get all the emails out the way. I mean, there's so many books on it saying that if you can do all your stuff, like Eat That Frog and all the other stuff where you do all the stuff in the morning, then And you leave the rest of the day for creativity. Yeah, by saying you can't send emails at 5 o'clock in the morning, that's, you know, that's not going to fit in with everyone's way of working
[16:18] Leanne Elliott: Yeah, and, you know, that's what, what Christian's found in, in his research, both through this survey and, um, into hybrid work, which I'm sure we'll talk about another episode. Um, there are typically kind of 4 clusters that, that he's identifying, and, and those 4 clusters of employees usually depend on whether they're an individual contributor or whether they're a line manager. It depends on their gender, their age, their years of tenure, and all of these things can, can feed into their preferences in terms of behaviours at work
[16:47] Al Elliott: So, we now know a little bit more about the actual behaviour study and the research. Let's find out what the judges are actually looking for. Here's Gill. So, we— it's all calculated quite scientifically, and so it's not— it's all data-driven decisions. And so initially we look at that environment, and so the metrics that we look in there is actually what are the comprehensive nature of the services that have been offered? Are their employees aware of the services? Are they using them? And most importantly, are they benefiting from them? So are you, are you offering the right things? But actually interventions can just be sticky plasters if you don't necessarily have the culture that allows people to utilize them. And feel, you know, it's okay for me to go for a walk at lunchtime. So it's, you know, the interventions are just sticky plasters unless you get that culture right. So we also look at that culture as how do people feel about that organization and their values? You know, is it a diverse, inclusive workforce? Are they being supported by their line managers? And so it's really trying to capture, is the workplace the right environment for us to thrive? So that's the first measure. The second measure then is purely a measure of health of those individuals. And we utilize a clinical algorithm that takes both in physical health metrics but also lifestyle behaviors to give you a health age. And we call it the Vitality Age, and it's the gap between someone's health age and their chronological age as we have as a determinant of health. So we look at this Vitality Age Gap overall for an organization to see how is the health of that organization. The final element then is, is actually what are the outputs? So what are as outcomes that an organization would be looking for if they've got a comprehensive wellbeing strategy, and that's where it comes to the productivity, engagement, satisfaction. The 4th measure we then look at is actually participation, because in order for it to be credible, you say you need a certain proportion of your population participating in the survey, and so you've got to get and reach a threshold to allow it to be statistically valid. But then if you go over and above that, the more that you get to That's so we give you more points to, to become overall Britain's Healthiest Workplace
[19:00] Leanne Elliott: This is awesome. So just to, to break down and recap what Gill said there in terms of what the judges are looking for. First of all, they are going to look at, um, the nature of services and interventions that are being offered. But the key thing here that Gill says, interviews can just be sticky plasters if you don't have the culture that allows people to utilise them. And I think that is massive. Otherwise, we are throwing money at interventions that people either aren't utilising or aren't meeting their needs. So I think that's a really great point from, from Gill there. And as part of that culture piece as well, they also look at diversity, inclusion, and as always, the line manager. The second measure then is, as Gill said, around health of those individuals. Um, so that's lots of questions about physical health, mental health, and lifestyle to get their vitality age. The 3rd element is outputs. What are the business outcomes an organisation should be looking for if they have a comprehensive wellbeing strategy? Positive wellbeing is good for business. It's as simple as that. And in terms of the threshold, what Gill's saying there, if we have 100 people in our organisation, but only 20 fill out the survey, that's not going to meet a threshold So we need to know that that data is scientifically valid. So you are going to have to get a minimum response rate in that survey in terms of percentage of your team
[20:24] Al Elliott: So we're now going to hear from Christian, the researcher behind it. He uses a term which I didn't know, and I'm not sure everyone will know, of ESG. What does that mean, Leanne?
[20:31] Leanne Elliott: ESG is environmental, social, and governance. It's basically a framework of non-financial factors that helps us understand and assess the risks and opportunities within an organisation that aren't financially related. Really, at the heart of this is the idea of sustainable business, and I think that's where Kristian is quite right to talk about bringing health into, into part of that conversation
[20:56] Al Elliott: So let's hear from Kristian. There's hardly ever a winner that, that does not have health and wellbeing as a key organisational priority. Typically, there's quite significant engagement with the board around around health and wellbeing. They tend to report on their health and wellbeing, almost a little bit like an ESG aspect of it, but I would call it ESGH. You know, health is an important dimension of that as well. And I'm actually working with Business for Health to bring the H into the ESG debate as well. And I think that's really important. Line managers' capacity. They tend to invest quite a lot in their line managers in terms of giving them training and upskilling them in terms of managing health and wellbeing of staff. And they typically have a really well-structured and branded health and wellbeing program as well, whereby, you know, it's easy to access. All employees understand exactly what the employer organization is doing around this, that they know it's important. Okay, so now let's talk about how you actually apply. Here's Gill. Yeah, so the survey is free of charge for any organization. Over 20 employees. To be clear, the 20 employees is because we need anonymous data, and so that's from a GDPR perspective. And we encourage every sector, as I say, it's completely free to participate. And you— the— at the back of it, what we do is we, we analyze that data and give not just your points to go towards the competition, but incredibly comprehensive review to address how's your well-being strategy, how's it affecting your people, how's it affecting So it doesn't matter whether you're completely new to wellbeing and you want to understand the risk factors and your starting point, or the likes of Novo Nordisk and Nomura who've got a really well-established wellbeing strategy and want to understand what's working well and what's not working well
