# Workplace Surgery: Managing hiring chaos without spending a fortune

- **Episode:** [244](https://agents.truthliesandwork.com/episodes/244.md) (2025-10-28)
- **Type:** workplace-surgery
- **Tags:** hiring, recruitment, budget, small-business
- **Time:** 35:16–40:57 (start 2116s)
- **Listen:** [https://truthliesandwork.com/244?t=2116](https://truthliesandwork.com/244?t=2116)

---

[35:16] Al Elliott: Bet they're a pain in the arse to work with. Bet they are. Anyway, we're on to the World Famous Weekly Workplace Surgery where I put your questions to Leanne. By the way, are there any links in the show notes for the previous truth or lie, or was it just all me?
[35:31] Leanne Elliott: Um, it's not made up, but if anyone does want the studies, yeah, I can leave links if you want
[35:36] Al Elliott: If you want the studies, email Leanne
[35:37] Leanne Elliott: Yeah, drop me an email, hello@truthliesandwork.com
[35:40] Al Elliott: Okay, so onto the world famous Weekly Workplace Surgery where I put your questions to Leanne. You know by now Leanne's a chartered occupational psychologist. I should be able to say that without stammering. A chartered occupational psychologist and also my former business partner based on the last few minutes. So question number 1, how do I manage chaos when hiring? Without spending a fortune. So I am a founder of a small tech startup. We're looking to hire our next team member. I'm excited about finding someone great, but the hiring process is an absolute nightmare. Right now we're posting on a few job sites and my inbox is getting slammed with hundreds of applications. I'm trying to review every single one, but it feels like I'm drowning. I'm worried I'll accidentally miss the right candidate and it's taking up so much of my time. Uh, we definitely don't wanna pay for an expensive recruitment system, but I do need a better solution. Lee, what, how, how can you help, Lee?
[36:27] Leanne Elliott: Well, I do have some thoughts on this in terms of, of being a recruiter for a small business that has a high number of applications, but I also wanted to bring in our friends at The Curve Group who specialise in high-volume recruitment. So here is Liam Read, Head of Recruitment Operations
[36:45] Al Elliott: Honestly, this one's always tricky. I hear this a lot. People jump straight to, let's get some fancy AI tool to do the first-round screening. But those systems can be seriously pricey, especially for a small tech startup. What I'd suggest, if the, the job boards do allow it, is to add maybe 2, 3, 4 absolute must-haves right into the job post before anyone can even apply. Most platforms then will just be able to auto-filter or reject applications who don't tick those boxes. That way you're not having to waste time. hours even sifting through all those irrelevant CVs. The system does that first pass, or the job board does that first pass for you, and you can spend time on those stronger matches. It's super simple, low-cost fix, but it can make hiring that feel less chaotic without needing that fancy recruitment software. Leanne, anything you would add to that, or any thoughts?
[37:44] Leanne Elliott: I think it's a really good tactic Um, Liam obviously knows what he's talking about, knows probably much more than I do about this world, but that's certainly something that I would always— I've always done, always recommend for organisations I work with, is to have that minimum essential criteria. And like Liam said, 3 or 4 points that are just non-negotiable. They're not the nice to have. You've proven through a job analysis that these things are fundamental for the role that you're recruiting for. Awesome. If you can get your platform to, to ask those questions and tick, tick. I think LinkedIn definitely does do that. I'm sure the platforms do as well. The only slight problem to be aware of with that is it could potentially lead to an increase in applications from majority groups such as white middle-class males who tend to overestimate their competence and may be more likely to tick those boxes even if they don't have the minimum criteria
[38:35] Al Elliott: I don't like the way you're looking me directly in the eyes when you're saying this
[38:38] Leanne Elliott: So, just to be mindful of, just to be mindful of, it might not necessarily stop some people from applying regardless. If you don't even have that capability on your job board, I'd say that's your first sift. And I think that's something that you can get, you know, a really great business support person to do, is that first sift where you look at the, the COVID letter and look at the, the CV and you just go, it has to hit these 4 points. It's a yes or a no. Yes, forward to the, the mailbox of the hiring managers
[39:09] Al Elliott: Mm-hmm
[39:10] Leanne Elliott: No, put it in a folder to send a sorry, you know, not successful on this occasion email. Because you're just going to rattle through them. And I think this is where some of the myths come from, where recruiters will only spend 10 seconds looking at a CV. And I'll be honest, in my first sift, I spend about 10 seconds looking because I need to see these minimum criteria. And then you can also have quality checks in there as well. So, everything that does go into the rejection pile, The hiring manager will then look through just to make sure, you know, look through 10 or so to make sure that it has been an accurate thing. But I think that's a really good, a really, really good idea from Liam there. Other things that I've done is then include as the next stage of the recruitment process, some kind of work sample test, nothing too—
[39:54] Al Elliott: Onerous
[39:55] Leanne Elliott: Onerous, thank you. But something that's maybe going to take the candidate 15 minutes, half an hour max to really hit some more essential criteria. In my experience, that usually sifts out about another 50 to 60% of people. You then still might not have dug into their CV in any more detail, but you're then going to have the results of the work sample test, which again, you're going to have indicators in terms of what good performance on that test looks like. At that point, you might go, right, this is a minimum criteria to pass as such. Anything that doesn't pass doesn't get through. Anything that does, maybe that's the point where we'll look at in more detail at the CVs, their specific experience, blah, blah, blah
[40:34] Al Elliott: Yeah
[40:35] Leanne Elliott: And move them on. If you've got a job that's going to get a lot of applications and you want to be thorough, having a really smartly designed recruitment process that is based on a job analysis and is predictive of work performance, it's really going to help you from a time perspective to, yeah, to get through as many as you can without overlooking really good people
