# Truth or Lie: The 10,000-hour rule

- **Episode:** [246](https://agents.truthliesandwork.com/episodes/246.md) (2025-11-05)
- **Type:** truth-or-lie
- **Tags:** 10, 000-hour-rule, skill, practice
- **Time:** 24:58–35:08 (start 1498s)
- **Listen:** [https://truthliesandwork.com/246?t=1498](https://truthliesandwork.com/246?t=1498)

---

[24:58] Al Elliott: I'll cut that out. Keep that in. Welcome back to Truth or Lie, which is part of Truth, Lies and Work podcast. It's all getting very meta, very confusing. Truth or Lie is basically a segment where we take the idea that everyone says is true and no one really questions. And we basically say to Lee, Leanne, you are a psychologist. Is this a truth or is this a lie? So today we are looking at the 10,000-hour rule. You've probably heard it. If you put 10,000 hours of practice in, you can master anything. The Beatles did in Malcolm Gladwell's book, Tipping Point. No, Outliers. I can't remember what it was in
[25:33] Leanne Elliott: Outliers
[25:34] Al Elliott: Outliers. And he said, he said that the Beatles had done 10,000 hours worth of practice of playing for like in random clubs. And they were masters, apparently. It does sound reassuringly. Success is just a simple kind of equation. You go, all right, put the time in, you get great out. But is that actually true?
[25:52] Leanne Elliott: Let's see
[25:54] Al Elliott: Let's find out
[25:55] Leanne Elliott: Let's find out. I've obviously heard of this one as well. If you haven't, let's start with where it comes from, shall we?
[26:02] Al Elliott: Okay
[26:02] Leanne Elliott: It doesn't start with Malcolm Gladwell. It starts back in 1993. A psychologist called K. Anders Ericsson And his colleagues studied violin students at the Berlin Academy of Music
[26:12] Al Elliott: No strings attached in this study
[26:14] Leanne Elliott: No strings attached. They found a pretty clear pattern. So the top performers had practised for around 10,000 hours by the age of 20. The good students had done about 8,000 hours and the less skilled ones close to 4,000 hours. So Ericsson's takeaway wasn't that there was a magic number. It was that the most accomplished people simply practised more And differently. So he called this deliberate practice. So it was intense, it was focused effort on weaknesses guided by feedback. So the teacher played an important role in this and designed to push just beyond one's comfort zone. So it wasn't just about practising, it was a specific type of practice that he found
[26:54] Al Elliott: Hmm
[26:54] Leanne Elliott: So then along comes Malcolm Gladwell in Outliers, he turned What was a pretty small academic finding into a pretty big cultural story in the only way Malcolm Gladwell can. So you're right, Al, the Beatles, he did talk about in his book, they were playing all night in Hamburg. Bill Gates coding for hours as a teenager. I think Ed Sheeran also talked about it on a chat show saying that he was a 10,000 hours believer. And all those examples do fit perfectly, don't they? It's, it was actually Gladwell that called it the 10,000-hour rule
[27:27] Al Elliott: Yeah
[27:28] Leanne Elliott: So, he coined that bit, and the idea went viral. Absolutely. To the point where I'm not even sure many people would track it back to Malcolm Gladwell
[27:35] Al Elliott: No, no
[27:36] Leanne Elliott: It's bigger than Malcolm at this point. To be fair, what we can understand from that is practice does matter a lot. In terms of other research that might back this up. So, in medicine, a study from 2020, if you're interested, Al, it's in the Journal of Thoracic and Cardiovascular Surgery
[27:53] Al Elliott: Oh, one of my favourites. I've got, In fact, I've got one waiting for me outside. It just should be delivered yesterday. Fascinating read
[28:00] Leanne Elliott: Fascinating. I've got a joke, but I can't quite get there. It's like it's on the pulse of something
[28:06] Al Elliott: Oh yeah, I was trying to think of organs and then I started to go down a different route that I probably shouldn't have done. Sorry. So Journal of Thoracic and Sporadic Cardiovascular Surgery
[28:15] Leanne Elliott: Yes, 2020 found that hospitals and surgeons performing higher volumes of lung cancer operations had lower mortality rates
[28:22] Al Elliott: Keep it light, Leanne
[28:23] Leanne Elliott: Lower mortality rates. This is light. They're not dying
[28:26] Al Elliott: Okay
[28:28] Leanne Elliott: Okay. So yeah, experience saves lives. In chess, we have some classic work from Simon and Chase, which also sounds like some kind of electric music
[28:37] Al Elliott: It does, doesn't it?
[28:39] Leanne Elliott: Simon and Chase in chess showed that grandmasters typically spent about a decade, often equating to roughly 10,000 hours, Internalizing over 50,000 patterns of play. Goodness. So we do have some evidence from outside of music. So yes, Ericsson's principle that expert performance comes from thousands of hours of focused effort has been held up across disciplines. The principle. Where Malcolm made a slight mistake is calling it a rule
[29:08] Al Elliott: Right
[29:09] Leanne Elliott: Because what don't psychologists like, Al?
[29:11] Al Elliott: Rules
[29:12] Leanne Elliott: Just absolutes. Absolutes. We're not a fan of absolutes. And that's what makes it problematic. So Ericsson never said 10,000 hours was a rule. In fact, he spent years correcting that misunderstanding. It was an average from one study of musicians, not a universal law. And this is the problem with all of these things. They're just overgeneralized. Some people do reach elite levels faster as well. Um, others take much, much longer. So there's other factors at play
[29:41] Al Elliott: Yeah
[29:41] Leanne Elliott: So, in Ericsson's later book, Peak, which he co-authored with somebody called Robert Pool, pleasant name, he said it may not require exactly 10,000 hours, but it will take a lot. So, the real insight—
[29:54] Al Elliott: I like you said a lot
[29:55] Leanne Elliott: Yeah, it's a lot
[29:55] Al Elliott: He's left that open there
[29:57] Leanne Elliott: A lot, which isn't like absolute, Sam. The real insight from Ericsson wasn't also, it wasn't just about time, as you'll remember, Al, it was about quality. Not all practice is created equal. So 10,000 hours of unstructured repetition, um, the musical equivalent of just like jamming
[30:15] Al Elliott: Playing Chopsticks
[30:16] Leanne Elliott: Yeah
[30:16] Al Elliott: Yeah
[30:17] Leanne Elliott: Um, doesn't build experience. Um, Ericsson actually called that naive practice
[30:21] Al Elliott: Oh, so can I just stop you? I just wanna make sure I've understood what we're saying here. So the, the 2 words sticking in my head is causation correlation. Is that what we're saying? That people are re— are looking at data and retroactively fitting a rule or taking a rule from it. So they'll go, 10,000 hours, I've got all this, all these case studies to back it up, and then going, that's the rule
[30:41] Leanne Elliott: Yeah. So what Ericsson found in his research was a correlation between the number of hours practiced and the competence of the musician. What Malcolm Gladwell has extended that to causation
[30:52] Al Elliott: Right
[30:53] Leanne Elliott: In that if you do 10,000 hours of this, you will be an expert in it. And there's other There's other things that are happening alongside that, as well as the type of practice you're engaging in during these 10,000 hours. So, neuro research, for example, 2014, uh, we have some psychologists that analysed 88 studies of musicians, athletes, and professionals, and their conclusion was that yes, deliberate practice explained about 26% of performance, but the rest came from other factors like cognitive ability, personality, and even look. And actually, if you look beyond musicians and athletes in professional settings, practice actually explained only 1% of performance
[31:38] Al Elliott: Wow. That's a, that's why it's a small number, but it's a lot smaller than I thought it was gonna be
[31:42] Leanne Elliott: Yeah. Yeah, it is. There's other researchers that have gone deeper arguing that the 10,000-hour story oversimplifies Ericsson's work, ignoring the role of mental representations. And so that's a detailed mental maps expert build through practice that allow them to anticipate and plan and adapt. That's what, um, regular listeners will know Chip Conley talks about in terms of wisdom work
[32:05] Al Elliott: Yeah
[32:05] Leanne Elliott: So it's not just— it's, it's, yeah, it's all these different mental representations, scenarios basically, that, that we've been through that allows us to anticipate, plan, adapt to something that happens in the moment more effectively. And that internal Knowledge isn't built by time alone. It does again come from how you practice and crucially who you learn from. Um, so yeah, then there's context again. More recently, Jamie North, 2012, from Leeds Metropolitan University. That's where you went, Al
[32:34] Al Elliott: Go on, Jamie
[32:35] Leanne Elliott: Uh, Jamie reviewed the deliberate practice model and found it fits well in highly structured environments like music or chess, but not in more open systems like management or teaching. So, the verdict, is it true or is it a lie? Does it take 10,000 hours to master something? It's true that mastery demands time and structure and sustained effort. There are no overnight experts. But it's a lie that the number itself, 10,000 hours, holds any real meaning. It's not a rule. It's a rough average. It's definitely not a guarantee because actually it comes down to the quality of practice that you are engaging in for said number of hours. So, Is it true? Not really
[33:17] Al Elliott: I suppose also, if you do spend 10,000 hours doing something, you've actually properly committed to something you're probably gonna do for a long, long, long time
[33:26] Leanne Elliott: How long is 10,000 hours, like, over time?
[33:29] Al Elliott: Oh, it's around about, uh, 600,000 minutes. Um, I dunno. How long is 10,000 hours in days? What, what?
[33:35] Leanne Elliott: So if you said 10,000 hours, let's say you practice for something like, what, an hour and a half a day?
[33:40] Al Elliott: Yeah. So, well, let's take 2 hours so I can, I can do the maths
[33:43] Leanne Elliott: Easy maths. Yeah
[33:44] Al Elliott: Yeah. Yeah. So that would give you 5,000 days. And let's say you practiced every, what, 5 days a week? Yeah. That gives you 100 weeks, which is about 2 years. So if you did 2 hours a day, 5 days a week, for, check my maths, listener, 2 hours a day, 5 days a week
[34:02] Leanne Elliott: For 2 years
[34:03] Al Elliott: For 2 years, you'd hit your 10,000 hours
[34:04] Leanne Elliott: It's not that long, is it?
[34:05] Al Elliott: It's not, is it? Mm-hmm. No, I think you'd be an expert in, uh, in Instagram by now, wouldn't you? But—
[34:11] Leanne Elliott: Or podcasting
[34:12] Al Elliott: Or podcasting
[34:13] Leanne Elliott: Clearly not. We could say, yeah. It's the quality of the practice hour. That's what we have not been engaging in
[34:18] Al Elliott: Let me choke on my water there. Yes. Well, there you go. So I like that. And also I'm really, really enjoying this series. So, um, but I'm starting to run out of ideas to what to ask Leanne. I've got 3 or 4 more, but if you're listening, we wanna hear your idea. What do you think? What is something which everyone believes in or believes is true, but actually may not be? I'm trying, wording that very carefully so we don't, we don't get sued for copyright by Radio 1, by Greg James. If you haven't listened to it, that's a great one. Unpopular opinion. That's how it goes
[34:50] Leanne Elliott: Just like that
[34:52] Al Elliott: Yeah
[34:52] Leanne Elliott: If you've got a myth that you want—
[34:53] Al Elliott: I'm not on Radio 1
[34:54] Leanne Elliott: You've got a psychological pop psych belief that you want proving or indeed disproving. Send us an email, hello@truthliesandwork.com, or come and find me on LinkedIn
[35:03] Al Elliott: Yeah. Okay. So, if you haven't followed Leanne on LinkedIn, go and join
