# Why people keep giving: the psychology of volunteering and recognition

- **Episode:** [246](https://agents.truthliesandwork.com/episodes/246.md) (2025-11-05)
- **Type:** news-roundup
- **Tags:** volunteering, psychology, recognition
- **Time:** 15:07–23:34 (start 907s)
- **Listen:** [https://truthliesandwork.com/246?t=907](https://truthliesandwork.com/246?t=907)

---

[15:07] Leanne Elliott: I have seen some research, Al, that asks the question, why do some people keep giving their time even when they start to feel taken for granted?
[15:16] Al Elliott: Hmm
[15:16] Leanne Elliott: Ever been there?
[15:17] Al Elliott: Yes, with you. No, I mean, yes, in a previous position
[15:21] Leanne Elliott: With me?
[15:21] Al Elliott: No, never with you. I was just, I was just making light. I was making light of the situation
[15:26] Leanne Elliott: You paint us to be such like an old boomer couple, like mansplaining, like, oh, I'm gonna pay for that later. It's like, really?
[15:36] Al Elliott: If anyone knows us in real life, they'll know that we are just exactly the same in real life as we are on here. We're always making jokes and I've never slept on the couch, so yeah. Don't break it down. Leigh, what have you seen?
[15:50] Leanne Elliott: So this research, it's what Mary Lou, who is a business psychology MSc student at the University of Leeds, at the University of Hertfordshire set out to explore in her dissertation. Now, the reason I'm sharing this— you might be going, um, MSc student, Leanne, why are we talking about this? Do we not need some, like, you know, PhD-level stuff? No, we don't, because research like this is from students, is bringing that fresh perspective. It's bringing the question that the young people have when they're not weighed down by workplace politics or corporate language. And as anyone who's been through academia will know, Any dissertation at this level is heavily supervised by a more senior psychologist, so this is legit research, and I thought it was really, really brilliant. So Mary's research looked at the psychology of volunteering using a framework called the effort-reward imbalance model. It is a theory that usually explains burnout at work, the idea being that if you give more effort than you feel rewarded for, your wellbeing is likely to take a hit
[16:50] Al Elliott: Okay
[16:51] Leanne Elliott: Intuitive
[16:51] Al Elliott: Yep, makes sense
[16:52] Leanne Elliott: But in the world of volunteering, things didn't quite play out in that way, Mary found. So she surveyed 118 volunteers across the UK and found that yes, they were putting in huge amounts of effort, and no, they didn't always feel rewarded, but those who described themselves as overcommitted— so the people who gave more than they probably should— actually reported higher levels of wellbeing
[17:18] Al Elliott: Now we've, we've, we've volunteered before
[17:20] Leanne Elliott: Yeah. That's how we met
[17:21] Al Elliott: That's how we met. Volunteered for the Samaritans. And we ended up both on the committee. Me, me being the chair of the committee, you being the head of training or recruitment, I think it was
[17:29] Leanne Elliott: Recruitment
[17:30] Al Elliott: Recruitment
[17:31] Leanne Elliott: Yeah
[17:31] Al Elliott: I have to admit, for a short period of time, I was more committed the more I took on. However, for me, it lasted about a year and then I was a bit like, I think I've taken on too much
[17:41] Leanne Elliott: Yeah, I think it's probably a bit longer than that, actually. I think it's about 2 years. Yeah, but yeah, it's easy for— I guess it sounds counterintuitive, but for us having been in quite a varied volunteer role with an organisation for a long period of time, we did get a huge sense of meaning from that, didn't we?
[17:58] Al Elliott: Yes, absolutely
[17:58] Leanne Elliott: A huge sense of purpose, and that is exactly what Mary's research concluded. So it seems that for volunteers, it's not the balance that matters, it's the meaning. So giving time and energy Makes people feel part of something bigger. They're not working for the money, they're working for purpose. And I think it's something that every business owner should really pay attention to, uh, because Mary also found that recognition was the most powerful motivator of all. I've been banging on about recognition all year, Al
[18:27] Al Elliott: And the irony is no one's recognised you for talking about recognition
[18:30] Leanne Elliott: I know, I know. So what she did is she analysed 87 written responses. The word recognition came up 20 times
[18:37] Al Elliott: In '87?
[18:37] Leanne Elliott: In '87
[18:38] Al Elliott: So that's about 30-33%. Lovely
[18:41] Leanne Elliott: More than anything else, volunteers didn't want grand gestures or financial rewards. They wanted to be seen. A simple thank you, a moment of appreciation, or someone noticing their effort meant more than any formal incentive. Younger volunteers also talked about learning and confidence. This is such a big one, I think. Um, training, uh, skills for the future. And older volunteers mentioned accessibility and flexibility, so small adjustments that help to, help to keep them contributing. I think this is such an important thing for both aspects of that in terms of age. So for older people who may not be as involved in their work anymore, maybe have retired, to allow that kind of keeping connected to something again bigger than yourself. And for younger people in terms of learning and confidence, like you said, I was leading recruitment at Samaritans or co-leading recruitment for Samaritans when I was 25
[19:33] Al Elliott: 35 years ago
[19:35] Leanne Elliott: How dare you, sir?
[19:37] Al Elliott: How dare you, sir?
[19:38] Leanne Elliott: How dare you, sir?
[19:39] Al Elliott: Yeah
[19:39] Leanne Elliott: Which is an opportunity I'd never get anywhere else in an organisation. So I think there is, it's such a, it's such a big thing. And when I went to my interview, future interviews, I was always asked about Samaritans. Sometimes that's all they wanted to talk about. So I think it is, again, such a, such an important thing. And we also know that from all wellbeing research that's done, and particularly I think it was a meta-analysis done by Oxford a couple of years ago that caused a bit of a kerfuffle, um, did actually find that volunteering was one of the few things that actually did have a positive impact on wellbeing. So I thought it's some really interesting research that brings a little bit of, a little bit of nuance we haven't really talked about before or haven't appeared in the research before. Um, but yeah, I think it comes down to people need to feel valued
[20:22] Al Elliott: So let me ask you, so if I'm a business owner listening to you and going, um, this woman, she knows what she's talking about, uh, you, not Mary Lou, although Mary Lou knows also
[20:30] Leanne Elliott: Yes, she does
[20:31] Al Elliott: She does
[20:32] Leanne Elliott: How dare you?
[20:32] Al Elliott: Sorry, sorry, Mary. I look forward to your angry email. But if they're listening to this and going, okay, so volunteering, recognition, getting it, cool, I love that. Are you suggesting that people then try and find volunteering opportunities outside of work? For their employees, or is there like a volunteering, like a sort of a mentoring situation within work? What are they supposed to do with this information?
[20:55] Leanne Elliott: I think there's, there's 3 main takeaways. One is that it isn't even about necessarily volunteering. If you wanna apply this type of, this type of psychological thinking in your organisation, it's all about purpose and recognition. Do your people have purpose and recognition, or as we call it in RX7, reason and recognition? So by purpose, it means how are they connected to the mission of the organisation? How do their values align with it? How do they get up in the morning and go, yeah, this is a worthwhile thing to do? And the recognition comes from, yes, it's salary, yes, it's benefits, but it's also going to be flexibility. It's also going to be individualisation. It's also going to be those thank yous, that kudos, and that very structured feedback that is very steeped in context. So Al, I loved it when I saw your email reply to that customer the other day. They were being a bit, a bit natty, weren't they? And what you did was be able to calm them down because you said this and you said that, and I thought it was brilliant. Like, oh, thank you very much. And that, that—
[21:52] Al Elliott: I already feel good about that, and there was no email
[21:54] Leanne Elliott: There was no email. Send it later. Because it's building your self-efficacy, your self-confidence in your ability to do your job, and that's a huge part of psychological capital, which is one of the 4 psychological states that we need to have positive wellbeing. It's so important. And in terms of volunteering, yes, if you are an individual in an organisation who doesn't feel this sense of purpose and recognition, but you have to stay there for now, go and volunteer, go and find your people, find those with the same values, get those learning and development experiences. If you are an organisation that's looking to invest in community and wellbeing, setting up a volunteer programme is something that could be really, really great. And if you can do that together as a team somehow, even So, conservation projects, or I don't know, something to do with the local community, how you can support that could be a really great thing to do. It's like, what, a one-day volunteering, a quarter? It doesn't have to be anything massive, but yeah, can be really, really effective. So, I love that research from Mary. Thank you so much, Mary. I did reach out to her and ask if she put a post on LinkedIn. I was like, I need to know more immediately. So, she sent me some more details. So, Mary, thank you so much. I'll leave a link to Mary's LinkedIn profile. In the comments so you can check out her Paris. And I'm sure if you are interested in her research, she'll send it on to you too
[23:05] Al Elliott: Fabulous. That was what— that was one of your best news roundups. I loved it
[23:09] Leanne Elliott: Really?
[23:09] Al Elliott: Yeah, I really enjoyed it
[23:10] Leanne Elliott: Thank you. Amazing what a break does, isn't it?
[23:12] Al Elliott: Eh, do you know what it does? And also, you didn't bring up longitudinal studies, so, uh, I'm pleased about that. Anyway, after talking of long, long periods of time, after the break, we've got our truth or lie segment where we're gonna ask, does it really take 10,000 hours to master anything? Or is Malcolm Gladwell full of whatever you think it is? I've just made the ad spit out her tea, so we'll see in a second
