# "You're reducing somebody to a number"

- **Episode:** [287](https://agents.truthliesandwork.com/episodes/287.md) (2026-03-26)
- **Type:** interview
- **Tags:** reducing-to-number, criticism, ai-hiring
- **Time:** 39:59–43:45 (start 2399s)
- **Listen:** [https://truthliesandwork.com/287?t=2399](https://truthliesandwork.com/287?t=2399)

---

[39:59] Leanne Elliott: There might be someone listening who goes, but you're reducing somebody to a number. You're giving them a score. You're giving them a 3 or a 4. Is that the right thing to do? Is that dehumanising somebody?
[40:11] Kate Young: It's a really fair question, and it might be a kind of overly pragmatic response, but I would always encourage anyone asking that question to say, what would you prefer? By which I mean, is it better we reduce someone to a CV that's screened in 20 seconds, and you get a decision based on bad data, bored recruiter? Yes, they are given a score at the end of the interview, and yes, it is used to make a recommendation as to whether they move forward. But that score is based out of all of the robustness that I've just described, all of the great questions, all of the great principles. So, ultimately, when you've got thousands of people in a hiring funnel, you need a piece of data to make a decision on, because there has never existed a time where all those thousands of people would've got a lovely face-to-face interview. That's just a kind of nirvana we like to imagine that was actually never real. We used to post off CVs and hear nothing back, and it was heartbreaking because, you know, you put it in the envelope, you put the stamp, and gone to the postbox, and you got nothing back. So, yes, it's just, it is a number, essentially, but it's a robust and fair number. And I think in a big, high-volume situation, that is the very best we can do for people
[41:20] Leanne Elliott: In terms of Any small business listening who's like, this sounds really cool, but clearly it's not something that I can— is accessible for me right now. What advice would you give them in terms of making their recruitment process more robust, more fair?
[41:35] Kate Young: Well, the best advice for a small business is find a friendly psychologist in your network. There's a lot of really great freelancers out there who will happily— and the thing about psychologists, I'm sure you've experienced this, Leanne, we just care so much about getting it right and being fair. So, most will just give 30 minutes, an hour. It's a bit like your free appointment with the solicitor everyone always talks about. It's kind of free. Most psychologists will give that little bit of advice. And it's kind of the Pareto principle. You can almost get 80% of the gain with 20% of the effort just by doing even rudimentary job analysis, just simply prompting people to sit down and go, what does this person actually do? Think. Don't think about who you like. Think about what they do. And then looking at your hiring process and going, are we giving the same interview to everyone in the same role, or are we just going off the cuff? And have we space to maybe introduce something a bit more structured here? And then also with the final decision-making process, how are we making that? Who's in the room? And how, again, how are we making sure it isn't the loudest person wins? Because we as psychologists call them wash-ups. You get everyone in the room and you say, oh, I like this, and I rated this, and I did that. And actually what happens there is just that the loudest voice typically makes the decision. So, there's some real low-hanging fruit that local friendly psychologists can probably direct you to with minimum effort. But failing that, go to Sapia.ai. We've made lots of white papers with some really good advice on there. They're definitely worth reading. There's good analysis in there, but also some really nice takeaway commentary. And there's lots of free webinars and resources around. Sapia do loads. I did one on inclusive hiring the other week, and they're a good free resource just to start educating yourself a little bit
[43:18] Leanne Elliott: Say there's a business owner listening who goes, this all sounds very nice, Kate and Leanne, And sure, I could get in touch and find a friendly psychologist, but you've already told me how this is really manual and really expensive and takes ages, and I don't have the time for that. I need to get somebody into my business quickly. What if I just send all the CVs, put them all into ChatGPT or Claude, ask them to pick out the one that matches the job description best, and I'll interview that one and hire that one? Could I do that?
