# When candour hurts the business (and someone poisons the chocolate)

- **Episode:** [302](https://agents.truthliesandwork.com/episodes/302.md) (2026-05-19)
- **Type:** news-roundup
- **Tags:** candour, communication, workplace-conflict, toxic-workplace
- **Time:** 22:03–32:58 (start 1323s)
- **Listen:** [https://truthliesandwork.com/302?t=1323](https://truthliesandwork.com/302?t=1323)

---

[22:03] Cait Donovan: So I was choosing this article, and I was thinking it's got to be something that annoys me or else we're not going to have any fun. So this article really annoyed me. The title of it alone, I mean, Henrico Castro-Piers, I think you're probably an amazing guy, but the title of this article is When Candor Hurts the Business: The Economics of Employee Retaliation. And basically he's saying that managers are giving like overinflated performance reviews to mediocre employees because they're afraid of what the employees are gonna do to retaliate against it
[22:37] Leanne Elliott: Mm-hmm
[22:38] Cait Donovan: They're gonna gossip, they're gonna work slower, they're gonna damage company products. There's a story in there about how somebody Dumped something into some— there was like a chocolate company, somebody dumped something into it and it had to— what was it? Oh yeah, a person dumped ethanol into a tank of melted chocolate in order to lash out
[22:53] Al Elliott: Oh wow
[22:54] Cait Donovan: Wow
[22:54] Al Elliott: That's not lashing out, that's killing people
[22:56] Cait Donovan: Like, so they had to dump it, obviously. And listen, if you have a company culture where people feel like they have to retaliate to that degree, the problem isn't performance reviews, sir
[23:11] Al Elliott: Totally agree
[23:12] Cait Donovan: Like, this is— and so, they're talking about how awful performance reviews are, and I don't disagree. I don't know if you guys— have I had you— have I told you guys to have Mike Goldman on your podcast? Because if I hadn't, I meant to, because he does something that he calls talent density, and he wants to replace the performance review system completely. And he's got a way to do it that I think is actually quite useful. And so, yeah, are performance reviews outdated and broken? 1,000%. Should we stop doing them because we're afraid of ethanol in our chocolate? I'm not sure that's the response that we should be creating. That's like letting, letting the child run the parent-child relationship. Like, no, no, they're not in charge here
[23:55] Leanne Elliott: It does seem a bit of a, bit of a step up, doesn't it?
[23:58] Al Elliott: It escalated quickly, as they say in Anchorman. Yeah, that really did. So let me just see if I understand this. So The argument is that if you tell someone that they're not performing great at work, then they're gonna go and put either ethanol or feces in your chocolate milk. Is that what we're saying?
[24:15] Cait Donovan: Yes
[24:16] Al Elliott: Yes. So did they suggest—
[24:17] Cait Donovan: That's precisely it
[24:18] Al Elliott: And did they suggest what we should be doing?
[24:20] Cait Donovan: He said, yeah, they can, managers can take 2 approaches. The first one he calls using sticks and carrots
[24:26] Al Elliott: Well, that's a revolutionary idea
[24:30] Cait Donovan: Yeah, right. Tying pay to performance, rewarding with bonuses and penalizing with pay cuts. You think that people are going to retaliate over a poor performance review, but they're going to be fine when you dock their pay?
[24:41] Al Elliott: Wow
[24:42] Cait Donovan: What? That's not like— this helps companies measure effort more precisely. I'm not sure that that's how that's going to work out. Like, weaponizing pay is— I don't think weaponizing pay is a smart choice?
[24:56] Leanne Elliott: No
[24:57] Cait Donovan: And then there's a second approach that says, use only carrots. Managers can reward strong performance while overlooking weaker performance, knowing retaliation can occur. No
[25:10] Leanne Elliott: Say that again. Say that again
[25:12] Cait Donovan: Managers can reward strong performance while overlooking weaker performance, knowing that retaliation may occur
[25:23] Leanne Elliott: Wow
[25:23] Cait Donovan: So you're just gonna avoid the problem? We're just going into avoidant behaviors
[25:29] Leanne Elliott: This is a genuine article. Yes
[25:33] Cait Donovan: That's why I wanted to, when you were like, find an article, I was like, oh, I got one. This is in Harvard Business School
[25:40] Leanne Elliott: Seriously?
[25:40] Cait Donovan: So this is not, this is not like a psychologytoday.com or like Elephant Journal. This is Harvard Business School. And so now there's a section called Restoring Harmony at Work. So if we're not gonna use the sticks and carrots, and that's sort of the old method, he's saying, for managers, this is how you restore harmony. Let small issues slide. That is like a fast track to ruining everything. First. The next one is decouple pay from negative feedback. Well, yeah
[26:09] Leanne Elliott: What?
[26:10] Cait Donovan: Yes. And 3, clarify the reasons for a poor review. Okay
[26:16] Leanne Elliott: This is groundbreaking work from Harvard
[26:19] Cait Donovan: This poor kid, because he probably did— like, he probably really worked really hard on this. So I don't want to, like, despair— like, I don't want to disparage him completely. But it— this, this whole idea— I think the biggest issue that I have overall, regardless of any of the individual sentences, is the idea that we should be really worried about retaliation in that way. You should not be treating your employees poorly enough That retaliation is their first response to a problem. If retaliation is the main response to a problem, then you've got a bigger issue at play in general, and that should be dealt with. So, if you're seeing employee retaliation as a systematic problem in your research, and you keep coming up against different styles of retaliation, which could be as big as throwing ethanol in the chocolate, And as small as gossiping at work and like decreasing morale. But like, if you're seeing retaliation on a consistent basis because of how people are being treated, then treat people better. It sounds revolutionary. Yeah
[27:28] Leanne Elliott: Yeah. I mean, you're right. Let's be, let's be generous to this person who spent good time and effort on this. I, on one hand, I can see it, but social media is a big a big element of this, isn't it? Because we see like the rage quitting and all that type of thing, and, and people talking very, very candidly about their employee experience if it hasn't been very good, and that can damage brands. And you've got things like Glassdoor, haven't you, where people can leave reviews and stuff like that. So I understand the element of, of protection. But like you said, Kate, if we're starting to see retaliation at this level, And yeah, you know, it starts as, you know, a bit of incivility and then works its way up. Dealing with the retaliation isn't the solution to focus on. As you said, it's why are people getting to this point anyway where it's escalating to that level? And the whole pay thing. Yeah, of course, especially these days, cost of living crisis and costs going up every day. Financially, people are struggling. So, you know, how much we're paid is important. But we know it's a very small percentage actually in terms of what motivates us at work, particularly once that salary threshold has been met and we can have some form of relatively comfortable life. It's not as motivating. But how you treat people, that's motivating. How you give them something to believe in and work towards, create great relationships and, and help them figure out some type of segregation between work and life so they don't burn themselves out. That's what makes the big difference
[29:01] Cait Donovan: Yeah
[29:02] Leanne Elliott: And doesn't piss people off to the point they want to poison chocolate
[29:05] Cait Donovan: Yes, they're— this is absolutely solving the wrong problem. And I feel like also, if we're talking about like Glassdoor and, you know, rage quitting and writing things on LinkedIn about like how terribly you were treated, to be honest, I'm not sure how much that's hurting companies anymore unless it's happening like super consistently. It's like if you— we both have podcasts that are both fairly popular, right? So if you have only 5-star reviews, people don't trust your reviews. Because they're like, well, that— those were your friends. Congratulations, you have 183 friends who officially were— are willing to take the 3 minutes out of their day to give you a 5-star review and say, I love the host, or whatever, you know. But if you have, you know, 200 reviews and 6 of them are 1 stars, you look more legitimate. So I don't know that these— like, unless everybody in the company is writing all this crazy stuff about them, it makes the person look like the crazy person and the company just look like a regular old company where somebody just wasn't a good fit, you know, like it wasn't the right place for that person. You don't like my podcast, that's fine, but that doesn't mean it's total garbage, you know. And so I think that even that part of the retaliation, there should be a little bit less fear because nobody trusts anything that has only 5-star reviews anymore
[30:22] Al Elliott: And also the 1-star reviews help you to Sometimes can make you more, more inclined to go like, say for example, you're going to a restaurant, right? And so it's a, it's a, it's a beautiful Thai restaurant and someone's given it 1 star. Go, they didn't have chips or fries in your case. Then you'd be like, well, this is the place for me because I don't want some of that. Yeah
[30:41] Cait Donovan: Or they're like, I'm allergic to peanuts. And it's like, well, there's peanuts in almost every Thai dish. Like, I, I, why did you go to a Thai restaurant if you're allergic to peanuts? Like, why? No, this is, this is the onion. Have you heard about the onion soup theory? No, because this went viral. So this was funny. Somebody posted a recipe for onion soup and the number of comments underneath it saying, well, I don't like onions, what else can I replace them with? And people were like, just go look for a different recipe. Like, don't read a recipe for onion soup if you hate onions
[31:15] Leanne Elliott: What?
[31:16] Cait Donovan: No, I'm not gonna— what are you talking about? But people have gotten so particular. About like, because our feeds are, are, you know, adjusted to us, our algorithms are set on what we like and what we wanna see and what we— so we're so accustomed to having everything set to our own preferences that when something doesn't match up, we lose our minds over it. But I think that that's really obvious to people on the outside. So while of course you don't want ethanol in chocolate, like I'm pretty sure that it wasn't just a performance review that led this person to this result
[31:48] Leanne Elliott: Yeah. And we need some friction in our, in our teams, don't we? That's how we, that's how we ideate and create and improve. We want some friction there
[31:58] Cait Donovan: Yeah
[31:58] Al Elliott: Wow. What an article
[32:00] Cait Donovan: That's a fun one, right?
[32:00] Leanne Elliott: Yeah. Well played
[32:02] Al Elliott: Yes. So the link will be in the show notes. Um, my— just funny, I, I did— I had no idea what you're going to say, Cait. Absolutely no idea. And you're going to see in a second how kind of so related this one is. So just set the scene, like if someone gets fired from a company these days, generally what happens is that they go to log in and they can't log in. And then they'll get a ping saying, we've got, we've, you know, we've got a call with HR in 20 minutes. And you're a bit like, oh shit. And I mean, yes, that's brutal. No, it's not humane. Is it smart? From the company's point of view, well, maybe it is because I wanna take you back to February the 18th, 2025. It was end of the working day and 2 brothers, Maneeb and Sohaib Akhtar, they get called into a Microsoft Teams meeting. They're fired and the call ends at 4:50. Now I'm just gonna double check what this—
