# Workplace Surgery: My star player has become my biggest headache

- **Episode:** [312](https://agents.truthliesandwork.com/episodes/312.md) (2026-06-23)
- **Type:** workplace-surgery
- **Tags:** management, employee-performance, coaching
- **Time:** 38:10–43:00 (start 2290s)
- **Listen:** [https://truthliesandwork.com/312?t=2290](https://truthliesandwork.com/312?t=2290)

---

[38:10] Al Elliott: What did I do? What did I do? Right. Oh no. All right, so we're gonna go into our 3 questions. First question is about a star player who's turned into the biggest headache. So this person writes, I run a small company and for 2 years one of my guys was genuinely brilliant. Then something shifted. There were missed deadlines. She pushed back on everything, and last week she told me that my feedback wasn't worth listening to
[38:38] ?: Wow
[38:38] Al Elliott: When I raised it, she said she's been carrying the team for years and I should be grateful. Hmm. Part of me wonders if she's right
[38:46] Leanne Elliott: Okay
[38:46] Al Elliott: But her attitude is starting to affect everyone else. Do I owe her patience or have I already been— Do you know what, Dr. J, there's a lot to unpack here. What's your gut instinct on this?
[38:58] Dr Jake Tuber: Oh, well, my gut instinct honed by years of expertise on the subject, Al, so I'm very qualified to weigh in on this particular case. If when she says, do I owe her more patience? If the question is, do I sack them right now, to use a British term, the answer is probably no. You owe them another conversation or two. And I think it's really about being forward-looking in that case, which is to say, you know, you may be right that you've been carrying the team. How do you think you're carrying them now? You know, how do you think that our interaction right now is helping the team going forward? That's a bit confrontational. I might not put it exactly that way, but I would really look and say, you know, you may be absolutely right in the past, but right now missing deadlines, pushing back on everything is jeopardizing all of the hard work she's put in to get the team here. So that's kind of where I would start the conversation, I think. But it does sound, you know, annoyingly insubordinate and seriously worth dealing with. I don't think it's just either you fire her Or you'd agree to let things go status quo. I think a conversation is warranted. What about you, Al? Where are your thoughts here?
[39:58] Al Elliott: I'm thinking of the US Office, which actually was better than the UK one, and Stanley, where he exploded one day and said, did I stutter? And that was genuinely, I think, shocking to everyone because he had pushed the boundaries as much as he possibly could. But that was the point where I think everyone in that room— I know they're all characters and they're made up. I know this, Dr. Jake, but it was very well acted that they'd gone over the line there. And all of this sounds to me like it's gone over the line. However, there's a— Leanne's voice in the back of my head just shouting or whispering the words sexily to me in my ear, toxic superstar. Is that what this is?
[40:34] Leanne Elliott: Toxic superstar. Toxic superstar
[40:36] Al Elliott: It's not as sexy as when she does it. It really isn't. No, it's not. But is that the similar thing or have I got the wrong idea?
[40:42] Dr Jake Tuber: It could be. There's a wonderful Harvard Business Review case study from years ago that I still occasionally use I believe it's called The Unmanageable Star Performer or something like this. And it really is a case where somebody is out running an offsite office at a location, and the person goes out to visit that office, and everybody there is feeling that they've been pushed too hard by this person. They're not being listened to, but this person's a real star. And sort of the case that the students have to deal with is, what do I do about this situation? I do think there's a bit of toxic star performer syndrome here, potentially. But I don't think the answer is just to look at this person as the challenge. Like, let's, let's look at what's going on with the kind of direction we're giving them. Why is it they keep missing deadlines? Is there something we should be doing? Is there something the team should be doing? So I certainly do want to consider that. But I also think that the smart way to consider that is to look a bit systemically first before we just look at this person as the source of the problem. They may be more of a symptom of larger organizational challenges than the cause, or certainly part of the cause, but not the entirety of it. That's kind of where my mind goes here
[41:50] Al Elliott: I think you've just given some really, really good advice there to just chill out a second. Don't go in there with your ego and go, how dare you talk to me like this? But also, don't lie down and go, oh my God, they've been so great. Because as you said, there was a line you said in there I really liked saying, you may well have carried the team, but how do you feel like you're carrying— what was it you exactly said?
[42:08] Dr Jake Tuber: Yeah, how is this helping them now? You know, another way to approach This conversation would be to go with them with genuine curiosity, but ideally framing it in an honestly self-critical way, which is to ask them, how come you feel as though you've been carrying the team for years and didn't voice it? What could I have done to make sure you voiced that you felt like you were doing more than was required or weren't doing enough? I hate the thought that I've been putting you in this position. Sort of come in hat in hand, not in an accusatory way. Why do you think this is the case? But— You know, how come you haven't had a chance to tell me about it? What have I done that's prevented you from being able to speak up so that right now this is how you speak out? That would be an interesting way to approach this because, again, it's putting the onus on you as the leader, as the manager in this case, to say, am I creating the circumstances for your success enough? And if I haven't been, let's figure out where I went wrong years ago so I don't keep making the same mistake for you going forward
