# The two-minute conversation that changed British comedy

- **Episode:** [313](https://agents.truthliesandwork.com/episodes/313.md) (2026-06-25)
- **Type:** interview
- **Tags:** british comedy, career turning point, conversation
- **Time:** 19:05–26:26 (start 1145s)
- **Listen:** [https://truthliesandwork.com/313?t=1145](https://truthliesandwork.com/313?t=1145)

---

[19:05] Al Elliott: Well, let's get into that. So that's the moment. So I believe I've written down here, 1998 to around 2000. 2000 was the time that you must have had the conversation with him about this. So how did it start? Did he start it? Did you start it?
[19:20] Mike Harle: Jimmy came to me and said, hey, Mike, you know, can I pop in your office for, you know, half an hour later on today? And just talk about something? And I said, of course, feel free, 2 o'clock. So there he is. I'm in the CMO office there. And Jimmy came in, sat down, and I kind of remember that what he was saying was, I've got a great opportunity here in front of me, Mike, and I don't quite know which way to go. He said, I've just been offered a job with Boston Consulting Group
[19:59] Al Elliott: BCG
[19:59] Mike Harle: Big name then, probably a massive name now. It was, you know, McKinsey, BCG. This was kind of the place to go. And he said, I'm thinking about taking it and leaving, you know, what do you think? And I said, I'm not sure your heart's in business, Jimmy. You know, I mean, isn't it just more of the same? Isn't it just a high-octane version of what you don't like now? You know, where you're going to be under more pressure, where the expectations are going to be higher, and your heart's not going to be in it. I said, it's flattering. Of course it is. Everyone likes to be approached by companies like that, you know. But I said, so How are the gigs going? I think at that stage he'd done maybe one or two, you know, in a pub, probably near his home in High Wycombe or something like that, you know. He said, you know, okay, quite encouraging. He said, it's, it's hard finding the material, you know, and I don't know if I'm, uh, you know, but, you know, I got a reasonable reaction, so I'm gonna do more. I Bugger it. Do that, Jimmy. That's where your heart is. That's where your passion is. That's what you want to do. That's where you want to be. I said, why not go flat out for comedy and really see if you can make it? You know, it'll be a lot of hard work. And he was never afraid of hard work in areas that he was passionate about. I also came from a family— I mentioned my brother was a musician, but I come from a family that's in the entertainment and media business, essentially. So these kind of jobs weren't necessarily for somebody else. They were for us. And so it didn't seem that bizarre suggesting someone go into comedy. as a branch of entertainment. And that bit of advice was the thing that made Jimmy take the left fork in the road, as he's acknowledged countless times subsequently. So it felt like a really, really important moment. And I'm glad I advised him to follow his heart and not his head
[22:39] Al Elliott: Was it an immediate thing? You said, Jimmy, I think you should go and— you should not take the BCG gig, you should go and pursue comedy, and he went, cool, next day, I'm off. Or did it take a little time for it to percolate?
[22:49] Mike Harle: I don't think it took long, Al. Um, my memory is that he might have slept on it, or we talked the next day, but it immediately felt right to him. And it was the right moment to have heard that from the right person. So everything clicked into place. And I set into process with our human resources people that Jimmy would make an exit. He got paid some money for exiting on a voluntary redundancy scheme, which I think still amuses him to this day, that he got voluntary redundancy for leaving a job that he couldn't stand. But, uh, yeah, he was, uh, quick onto it. And, you know, the evening gigs were ramping up and Jimmy was getting more and more active. It was, uh, it was a pretty immediate reaction. And I think probably within a couple of months, January 2000, he was gone. And I remember I think I moved on maybe, or I was out of reach for some reason. But on the day that he left, he wrote me a charming letter, really nice letter, thanking me for what I'd done, for the things that I'd said, for being the right person at the right time for him. And I remember his closing sentence, Al, which was, so So, Mike, I'm off to join the circus. I'm off to join the circus. Cheers, Jimmy. And, uh, that's what he did. So no great deliberation, no BCG. Jimmy was off to join the circus, and he's still there
[24:54] Al Elliott: We actually have a lot in common. We both use behavioral science to help people do better at work
[25:15] Leanne Elliott: The audio destination for business professionals
[25:56] Al Elliott: It can
[26:04] Leanne Elliott: But come back
[26:05] Al Elliott: Yeah, come back. Definitely come back because Nudge isn't as good as this
[26:07] Leanne Elliott: So come back
[26:08] Al Elliott: I've got that. Keep that in. Most managers would never do something you've done there because they'd either want to keep someone like Jimmy because even though they weren't great at the job, they were still like, obviously, you know, people liked them around the office
[26:26] Mike Harle: Sure
[26:26] Al Elliott: Or there's perhaps a little bit of professional jealousy going, well, I'm going to stick here in Shell and you're going to go off and do an exciting, like you're going to be a comedian. What made you put Jimmy's career first over what you actually needed as a manager?
