# Truth or Lie: Work and fun don't mix

- **Episode:** [318](https://agents.truthliesandwork.com/episodes/318.md) (2026-07-14)
- **Type:** truth-or-lie
- **Tags:** work-fun, truth-or-lie, workplace-culture
- **Time:** 31:30–49:44 (start 1890s)
- **Listen:** [https://truthliesandwork.com/318?t=1890](https://truthliesandwork.com/318?t=1890)

---

[31:30] Al Elliott: Welcome back to Truth or Lie. It's that time of the week where we take a popular workplace idea and ask if the research really does back it up. Today we're testing the claim that work and fun don't mix. Leanne, I think we've all heard some kind of version of it. You're not paid to have fun. Mm-mm
[31:48] Leanne Elliott: No, sir
[31:49] Al Elliott: Rebecca, you've said this for generations. Work has been treated as the serious part of life, whereas fun is what you do after 5 PM. So if people are laughing or chatting or just generally mucking about, it must mean less work is getting done. Is that right, Leigh?
[32:06] Leanne Elliott: Well, you know, I need to first of all define fun because if psychologists suck anything out of anything, it's the fun outta the room
[32:15] Al Elliott: That's the least fun thing you've ever said
[32:17] Leanne Elliott: So when psychologists research fun at work, they're basically looking at things like joking with colleagues, celebrating successes, maybe taking part in some kind of games or social activities, events. Or just simply work in an environment where people are enjoying themselves. So, that's what we're looking at when we talk about fun. And when we're talking about whether work and fun mix, we're comparing it with outcomes. So, things like productivity, performance, employee engagement, wellbeing, relationships between colleagues, all the good stuff. So, are we clear what fun means and whether, whether it mixes with work?
[32:51] Rebecca Taylor: Thanks
[32:52] Leanne Elliott: Are you on the same psychologist boring page? Yeah
[32:55] Rebecca Taylor: On the same page
[32:58] Leanne Elliott: So, in terms of the case for that work and fun don't mix, there is some research done by John Michael, who has been on the show previously
[33:06] Al Elliott: Oh, we know him. Yeah, yeah
[33:07] Leanne Elliott: Yeah, with some of his friends. Um, they undertook a review of workplace fun literature in 2018. They pulled together decades of research, and they argue that workplace fun isn't something managers can simply switch on. So, employees judge fun at 3 different stages: before an activity starts, while it's happening, and afterwards when they reflect on whether it was worthwhile. Psychologists call this the anticipatory appraisal
[33:33] Al Elliott: The what, sorry?
[33:35] Leanne Elliott: I struggle with that word. Anticipatory
[33:38] Al Elliott: Nice
[33:38] Leanne Elliott: Anticipatory
[33:39] Rebecca Taylor: It's a tough one. That's a tough one. There's a lot of sipity-pities
[33:41] Leanne Elliott: And there's lots of, lots of, I struggle with lots of vowels, I think
[33:45] Al Elliott: Yeah, yeah. And also, Rebecca, you Americans like to take vowels out of things. How do you say anticipatory?
[33:49] Rebecca Taylor: Oh yeah, I would probably be like anticipatory. I don't know, I'd probably say it like that, but like I would say it so quickly that like you wouldn't even know if I messed it up. Yeah, yeah, that's why I'm so slow. That's my New York coming in though, to New Yorkers, we just drop things all the time. So it's just like, hey, you know, you fill it in
[34:03] Al Elliott: Anyway, I'm sorry, I digress. We digress. Anticipatory appraisal. Is that what you're saying?
[34:08] Leanne Elliott: Yes, exactly. They concluded that if people expect an activity to be awkward, childish, or a waste of time, unsurprisingly, they're more likely to resist it. And if it feels forced rather than voluntary, it can create frustration and emotional exhaustion instead of kind of the happy, positive emotions we were hoping for. And that idea does show up in the actual workplace as well. So some researchers called, and you know, I Join names, Al. Barbara Plester
[34:33] Al Elliott: Plester. That's a name
[34:35] Leanne Elliott: That's a good name. Strong, solid name, isn't it? And Anne Hutchinson spent 4 months in 4 New Zealand-based organisations, and they were observing everyday behaviour, and they interviewed 60-ish employees as well. They found a very clear difference between spontaneous fun that naturally emerged, um, and what they called managed fun. I think if you put manage in front of anything, it ain't fun, but especially in front of fun, it's really not fun, is it?
[35:02] Rebecca Taylor: No, no, we always called it forced fun
[35:03] Leanne Elliott: Forced fun, right? Yeah, yeah. Which is basically— it was, yeah, what you're saying, Rebecca. It's activities that were organized by the company. So things like mandatory pajama days— ick— uh, dressing up as TV characters, um, things like that. Unsurprising reviews: childish, contrived, and at times emotionally invasive. So rather than boosting morale, some employees became cynical, frustrated, and even admitted deliberately calling in sick to avoid taking part
[35:32] Rebecca Taylor: Guilty, guilty
[35:33] Al Elliott: Yeah
[35:34] Leanne Elliott: There is also some evidence that too much fun negatively impacts wellbeing. So one of the broadest pieces of evidence came from a review in 2021. So rather than carrying out a single experiment, these researchers analysed 326 research papers spanning 40 years in 18 different disciplines. Al, what is that called?
[35:53] Al Elliott: It's called a meta-analysis
[35:54] Leanne Elliott: Yes, sir, it is. So they did that to understand what happens when work and leisure become, um, increasingly Racing with Blood, and they found that if organizations integrate work and play too closely, employees can struggle to switch off mentally. So rather than helping people recover, highly blended environments can encourage workaholism and create role confusion and make it harder for people to detach from work at the end of the day. So basically, making work feel more like play doesn't mean people are healthy. It just kind of workaholism. Um, and then there are some practical concerns as well. Um, so some other research in 2022, they explored 4 Swedish workplaces designed to be deliberately playful. You know, the ping pong tables and the, the slide that Stephen Bartlett famously had in his Manchester office
[36:42] Rebecca Taylor: Ping pong tables. I just can't even— I have so many things to say about ping pong tables, but I won't do that here
[36:47] Leanne Elliott: Yeah, well, no, please do. This is exactly the place to do that. Um, but anyway, yeah, these, these types of offices. Um, so through interviews with employees and by observing behavior as well. They found that while participants liked the atmosphere overall, open-plan leisure activities, particularly activities like a table tennis setup, created enough noise, surprisingly, to disrupt concentration, with some employees choosing to work from home instead. Participants also questioned whether highly playful workplaces were appropriate in industries where safety, precision, or professionalism were especially important. So yes, there is evidence that work and fun don't always mix, specifically If it feels imposed rather than chosen, it blurs the boundary between work and home, or simply becomes a distraction, it can undermine concentration, recovery, and as we've heard, an employee's willingness to engage. So, so far it sounds like fun and work don't really mix
[37:45] Al Elliott: Yes. So Rebecca, before we go to the against, any thoughts on what we've just heard?
[37:48] Rebecca Taylor: It's like, it's one of those things where when you look at something like, like bringing games into the workplace, like having, you know, Ping pong tables, table tennis, like all of that. It just sets this weird sort of expectation where are people playing? Are people able to play? When are they allowed to play? If I'm on a sales call, can you hear it happening in the background? That's the kind of stuff that I had to deal with all the time. Um, or it kind of like creates this layer of expected ethics or unspoken workplace behaviors where it's like, I had so many times where we had a ping pong table in one of my old companies. The sales manager would come up to me and he would say, why are these 2 people playing ping pong? So-and-so's behind on his sales goal. And I'm like, I don't know. Like, are they not allowed to play ping pong when they're not behind on their sales goal? Did you tell them that? Did they know that? You're their manager. Why don't you deal with it? It just creates all these other, besides the whole ping pong's annoying thing, it just creates all these other unspoken workplace behaviors that people are judged by without that expectation actually being clearly communicated
[38:51] Al Elliott: Yeah
[38:52] Rebecca Taylor: But maybe that's my non-fun take on fun
[38:54] Al Elliott: I get, I get this. And also it brings back for certain people like myself, brings back into a school situation where there were the sporty cool kids who could play ping pong. And then there's the me who would try and hit the ball, trip over my own shoelaces and end up just falling on my ass. And so it just, yeah, same with like non-uniform day at school. And then also if you wear a uniform, you can bring in whatever you wear at You wear at home, then you get judged on what you're wearing at home. And I turned up in my £3 Walmart trainers and everyone's like, oh, look, he's got no money, which was actually true at the time. But it's, yeah, it's just a whole like thing, isn't it, Leanne?
[39:31] Leanne Elliott: There was nothing more stressful than an own clothes day
[39:34] Al Elliott: Yeah
[39:35] Leanne Elliott: I just think school should have a uniform and just remove that level of peer pressure
[39:40] Al Elliott: And no, especially when you're not cool
[39:42] Leanne Elliott: Yeah, it's like me
[39:43] Al Elliott: Yeah, not like Rebecca
[39:45] Leanne Elliott: Yeah, no, Rebecca
[39:47] Rebecca Taylor: Anyway, no, same. I wore uniforms growing up in school and I loved it. And then whenever it was like don't wear your uniform day, I was like so stressed out about it because I was never one of the cool kids. I was never ever like, it wasn't even about like who could afford what, it was about what was your sense of style, what was your taste? And I was like, I don't really know. And then it became a whole thing with like, oh, you're wearing that. I'm like, I thought this is what we were wearing. And they're like, this is what you were wearing last year. I mean, there's famously teenage girls are not very nice to each other. So I experienced a lot of that. I'm like, this would've been great if we just wore uniforms again
[40:20] Leanne Elliott: Yeah, definitely
[40:22] Al Elliott: Definitely. I never thought about that actually. As a boy, like a 13-year-old boy, there's certain ex— you know, it was quite stressful, but I imagine a 13-year-old girl, it would be a million times more stressful
[40:33] Rebecca Taylor: The worst. I'll never forget when low-rise jeans started becoming popular and I didn't know. So I came to school with like mid-rise jeans and everyone else is wearing these like super low-rise jeans that I've never been able to pull off. And they were like, you're dressed like a mom. I'm like, what?
[40:46] Al Elliott: What do you mean?
[40:47] Rebecca Taylor: And my butt crack's not hanging out and yours is
[40:52] Leanne Elliott: Low-rise was a tough, tough time
[40:54] Rebecca Taylor: I don't know what it is. And they're back and I hate it. I know
[40:59] Al Elliott: I don't understand what it is
[41:01] Leanne Elliott: You know how in the noughties where you'd always see basically, you'd look at the back of a woman's jeans, you'd see the top of her like knickers or—
[41:09] Al Elliott: I was very respectful. I never looked below the shoulders. That was me. Anyway
[41:15] Leanne Elliott: Well, today—
[41:16] Rebecca Taylor: Bring back the whale tail
[41:17] Al Elliott: But what the hell's a wet— no, never mind. No, no, no, we're going down
[41:21] Rebecca Taylor: Different podcast
[41:22] Al Elliott: Right. Different podcast, different audience. Leanne, what's the argument against?
[41:28] Leanne Elliott: So the argument against starts with the argument that forced fun isn't really fun at all
[41:33] Al Elliott: Yeah, I think— yeah, I'm with that
[41:35] Leanne Elliott: Yeah, I think that says it all really, doesn't it? So yes, employees do dislike company-organized activities like mandatory pajama days or dressing up. The New Zealand research that we just heard about also concluded that spontaneous humor between colleagues has the opposite effect. So, after spending 4 months observing these workplaces and interviewing employees, the researchers found that joking together gave people a mental break from demanding work, helped them recharge, and strengthened relationships within teams. And quite interestingly, the researchers also found that employees could dislike the work itself, but feel highly engaged with the organisation because of the social environment around them
[42:12] Al Elliott: Oh
[42:12] Leanne Elliott: That finding runs through some wider research that was conducted in 2020, or it's a review in 2020. They examined 11 of the most common myths about workplace fun, including the idea that work and fun don't mix. So, looking across decades of research, they found very little evidence to support that belief. So, instead, the literature consistently linked workplace fun with high energy, greater creativity, stronger attendance, increased loyalty, and better organisational performance. That review also challenged the idea that fun has to be expensive or carefully planned. They pointed out that around 80% of workplace humour and laughter happens spontaneously
[42:50] Rebecca Taylor: Hmm
[42:52] Leanne Elliott: Suggesting again that most— the most effective fun is often the kind that develops naturally rather than being organised by management. But what happens when organisations do introduce something more structured? Well, some researchers looked at exactly this in 2014, and they followed more than 230 salespeople at a technology company. And it's over 2, 3 weeks. One group took part in a basketball-themed sales game. Another simply saw a public leaderboard showing sales ranking. And a third group carried on as normal. The employees who embraced the game experienced significantly higher positive emotions, so feeling very, very happy, much higher than other groups. But simply displaying performance rankings without the playful elements actually reduced performance. So, the research concluded that it wasn't competition that exactly made the difference, it was the experience of play and providing employees—
[43:47] Rebecca Taylor: Mm-hmm
[43:47] Leanne Elliott: Um, with that experience, so long as they genuinely bought into it. Um, and finally, the benefits don't have to come from organized activities at all. According to a systematic review in 2023, they looked at something many managers might discourage, uh, brief periods of personal internet use during the workday. Is that okay? I don't know. But the research found, and this is from around the world, that these micro breaks, whether it be looking at YouTube or browsing online or playing a quick computer game, helped to restore attention and mental energy. And one study even found employees who took moderate digital breaks were 9% more productive than those that didn't. The key though was moderation. Once those breaks exceeded around 12% of the working day, they became counterproductive
[44:39] Al Elliott: Interesting. Interesting. By the way, if, um, if anyone's listening and they want to know how to be funny at work without going to HR, then go to episode 269, uh, with, uh, Beth Sherman, and, uh, she explains exactly how to do that. Leanne, do we— can we go to Rebecca and get her thoughts at this point?
[44:55] Leanne Elliott: What do you reckon? Truth or lie? Work and fun don't mix
[44:58] Rebecca Taylor: So, um, I think it's a lie with a caveat. So, Have you heard the term social effervescence?
[45:07] Leanne Elliott: Mm-hmm. I have
[45:09] Rebecca Taylor: So I read about it first in the New York Times, which sounds so obnoxious of me to say, but—
[45:14] Al Elliott: Can I just read, just in case anyone didn't hear about that? You wrote about it first in the New York Times might be the greatest sentence
[45:21] Rebecca Taylor: Read about it. Read about it. Didn't write about it
[45:24] Al Elliott: I will take that out
[45:24] Leanne Elliott: I will take that out
[45:25] Al Elliott: I apologize. I thought you said you wrote about it and I thought, oh my God, that's awesome
[45:31] Leanne Elliott: No, no, no
[45:31] Rebecca Taylor: That would be a flex. I would definitely have mentioned that way earlier
[45:36] Al Elliott: So, you read about it in the New York Times?
[45:37] Rebecca Taylor: I read about it in the New York Times. It was an article that came out around, I think it was 2021. So, it was sort of a social article talking about what we were missing from the pandemic. So, what was sort of the impacts that we were feeling? Why was loneliness, you know, becoming such a thing that we were all experiencing more, even though in a lot of ways we're more connected than ever? But it came, they introduced the term social effervescence, which is essentially the concept of when people are in a group together, whether they know each other or not, and they just start playing off of each other. They start either teasing or bouncing ideas off of each other or just inserting each other in conversations, you know, asking each other questions just like, if it were an apocalypse, what role would you play? Would you be the fighter? Would you be the hunter? Like, what would you do? Just introducing these types of kind of pieces where people can just bounce off of each other. That's considered social effervescence. So, when in this research, Leanne, that you mentioned, The moments where it's mentioned that fun is sort of appropriate for work, I would call that social effervescence. All of the, all of the footage that we're seeing about fans enjoying the World Cup together, you know, the rowing, you know, everybody rowing, everybody sort of like bantering with each other, that's social effervescence. That's just people experiencing a shared moment together and organically just finding ways to enjoy it together and finding ways to contribute to it together
[46:58] Leanne Elliott: Yeah
[46:59] Rebecca Taylor: And that to me is where work can be fun, but it has to happen organically. The thing about social effervescence is it doesn't start with like a corporate icebreaker. It doesn't start with a pizza party. It starts with a group of people who feel like they can trust their environment and they trust each other. And it's more, uh, a, a result of a really healthy environment that people are in. where it actually allows them to kind of bring some of their guard down, let some of their own humor in, and form connections, genuine vulnerable connections. Vulnerable meaning even just laughter. Like, laughter can be very vulnerable when it's like real genuine and authentic, but you can't orchestrate that without orchestrating a culture of trust that rewards that, or at least that allows that to happen
[47:47] Leanne Elliott: Yeah, I think it's, it, I, I think you're right. It's a, it's a truth with a caveat, or it's, it's kind of like we don't really know, or neither
[47:54] Rebecca Taylor: Yeah
[47:55] Leanne Elliott: I think essentially, as you kind of said there, we're kind of asking the wrong question, because as you say, Rebecca, it's much more organic, it's much more spontaneous, and that is where these relationships are nurtured. And we know relationships are one of the biggest drivers of all the good stuff in the workplace. In terms of the evidence, it doesn't suggest that work and fun don't mix, but it also doesn't show that simply simply adding fun makes organizations more successful. And there's a few problems. Psychologists, as I kind of mentioned at the top, that we're measuring lots of different things under the umbrella of fun, um, whether it be humor, whether it be organized social events, gamification, digital breaks, enjoying the work itself. Those aren't the same experience. So surprisingly, we're not finding any consistent results from looking at them. But what does seem remarkably consistent is that forced fun rarely works. Rarely works. So, these structured activities only really succeed when employees genuinely buy into them, and that's difficult because fun is subjective. One person's brilliant team-building exercise, the dressing-up-the-pyjama day, is going to be the reason that another person calls in sick. So, I think perhaps a more interesting finding is that the strongest results come from workplaces where fun, exactly as you said, Rebecca, emerges Naturally, it's the places with good relationships, with psychological safety, with autonomy, with mutual respect. They tend to have more laughter, more spontaneous humor, and better outcomes. So yeah, it isn't— fun probably isn't the thing that organizations should try to create, but it is a thing that will appear if you've got all the human stuff right
[49:39] Al Elliott: Thank you so much, Leanne. Links, I'm guessing, to all of these complicated studies are in the show notes
