# Theme 6: Line managers are EVERYTHING

- **Episode:** [37](https://agents.truthliesandwork.com/episodes/37.md) (2023-05-03)
- **Type:** other
- **Tags:** line-managers, management, employee-experience
- **Time:** 38:00–48:03 (start 2280s)
- **Listen:** [https://truthliesandwork.com/37?t=2280](https://truthliesandwork.com/37?t=2280)

---

[38:00] Al Elliott: So the 6th theme was it's down to the line manager. I've learned this from Leanne. If there's one thing you have to get right, it's having leaders and line managers who know how to both lead and also support. So Leanne spoke to Andrew from Mind, the mental health charity in the UK, who've been measuring the impact of line management for 7 years. Our Workplace Wellbeing Index is our benchmark of best practice across the UK
[38:25] Leanne Elliott: It's been operating now for 7 years
[38:27] Al Elliott: We've had 384 Yeah. Or different organizations participate. We've got a ridiculous number of data points, something along the lines of 45 million data points through individual questions. And each year we have about 50,000 employees answer various questions about mental health in their workplace. So every year, following that kind of cycle of surveying and benchmarking best practice, we produce our Index Insights. And that really says, year on year, what are the trends that we're seeing in a workplace setting, and what are some of the recommendations that we might have for different organizations based on some of those. And some of the key things that have really come out this year are about culture and about line management. So the key statistic that I've been talking about today has been the fact that only 52% of employees who completed the Workplace Wellbeing Index would say that they feel supported by their organization. Now, that is a 6% decrease on last year. To some extent, we think that is related to a bit of wellbeing fatigue. And we also know that those employees have also said that they've seen a reduction in the amount of promotion from their organizations around employee mental health, around wellbeing, signposting to support services. So there's been an 11% reduction in the number of employees who have also said that they've seen that level of promotion. But that does mean that there's 48% of employees who do not currently feel supported in their business. So we know that's a Yeah. A significant number of employees. Obviously, there's a number of wide-ranging factors in the workplace and outside of the workplace that are impacting on people's mental health at the moment. But another kind of important statistic that's come out of this year specifically has been looking at the significant impact that line managers play in that level of support. So thinking about employees who say that they have supportive line managers, they're twice as likely to report good mental health outcomes. compared to those that say that they don't have supportive line managers. And similarly, when looking at employees who say that they have effective working relationships with their line manager, they're 3 times more likely to report that they are happy at work than those that don't. So we know that line managers have a really important part to play in satisfaction at work, how productive they are at work, and their mental health outcomes at work. So that's been a lot of the narrative that we've really been talking about today. about how do we take those findings and recognize the importance of line management and translate that into some practical action
[40:45] Leanne Elliott: Oh, that gives me shivers. That gives me shivers. As like, I'm thinking back to my time as a manager. If I'd have heard that statistic, I'd be going through the people on my team going, are they okay? Are they okay? Are they okay? Are they okay? It's just, unless you are all over this, unless you have, you know, dedicated training to your line managers, coaching for your line managers, then there is a really, really good chance 50% of your employees do not currently feel supported. And in terms of that practical action, we are actually currently putting together a line manager training with our friends at Ride the Wave Coaching. So, if you are interested in that, and it really is a cool course, if you are interested, get in touch and we'll have a chat with you about kind of giving you an early preview of what we're putting together
[41:29] Al Elliott: We're going to be hearing a lot more from Andrew from Mind in an upcoming episode, but in the meantime, we will leave a link to this Minds So we heard some really compelling data points there from, from Andrew
[41:41] Leanne Elliott: But as we've said before, you know, often data doesn't induce the empathy we need to, to step up and, and support our people. So let's hear from Thomas and his candid thoughts on the difference it would've made to him to have more support with his mental health and wellbeing
[41:55] Al Elliott: It's weird. Like, I, I, I, I classify myself as speaking for what I call the silent majority. And I think the silent majority of people really struggle with mental health and wellbeing. Really just want the tools to help themselves out of the wood. And that's what I'm trying to achieve for people. And that's what I'm trying to give them as simply and as easily as I can along the way. I don't think that you can inherently change how people operate if they're an enigma or a bit of a dynamo. Or I think you've got that in you or you haven't. Is that X factor, let's say, like, not that I'm a twat and I think I've got the X factor. Fucking hell, what a dickhead
[42:31] Leanne Elliott: Right
[42:31] Al Elliott: So it's not about like, I don't think you can change it. If someone has that X factor or that energy, you see it all the time, right? On Britain's Got Talent, their gran might have died or their dog's had a bum leg and they still get a record deal, right? Oh, sad story
[42:41] Leanne Elliott: Boo-hoo
[42:42] Al Elliott: But at the same time, I think that everyone deserves support. And I think that I would've certainly been more stable and been able to find my fit more readily had I been given the tools and support at that stage. And I'd probably be a professional actor at this point. kicking ass on stage or in a movie or something. So I think it— yeah, I wish I'd had that support. It's a shame that I had to deal with another layer of trauma on top of that childhood before I got to this stage where I am now and people start sitting up and taking notice
[43:13] Leanne Elliott: Cass also believes that the starting point to level up line managers is pretty clear: educate them. I've worked with some of those leaders when I was in sort of salaried roles, and they are, you know, leadership teams that have been there for many, many years, and they're still learning, right? So, I think the key is education and making sure that those people understand exactly why you're doing the things that you do. So, as well as doing all the public-facing stuff, and also asking staff for their feedback, I think there's a really important education piece. So, training staff on things like unconscious bias, training staff on things like wellbeing, diversity and inclusion, and making sure that everyone, including leadership, board members, senior level, are educated as well, and that they are also doing those training courses because then they can, you know, they're the one you need their buy-in to be able to action anything. So I think educating those people is, you know, the starting point
[44:02] Al Elliott: So Nick from Co-Team also agrees that great leadership in 2023 looks quite different. These so-called soft skills that we were talking about 5 years ago are now essentials. In fact, he started Co-Team exactly to help businesses upskill managers in these essentials of soft skills. Here's Nick. I've spent about the last 10 years or so working in the space of digital transformation. So working with lots of leaders, trying to understand the sort of pace of change that digital is enabling and how to respond to that, attitude towards risk, organizational agility. And Co-Team was born out of the pandemic. I noticed a lot of the sort of soft skills that we were talking to leaders about staring in the face of digital were actually super relevant to many different people working in different organizations. We also combined that with focus on wellbeing, staff wellbeing, understanding why people burn out, but also importantly what leadership or management should be spotting for that and doing about it. Why the notion of leadership or management has changed in 2023, the idea of empathy and vulnerability and these types of things. So that's very much what we do at Coating. We run training programs to help managers be better managers and look after their people. So one of clients is H&M Group. And not to generalize, but being a Swedish company, I feel like they seem to be a lot more forthcoming in the way that they will— their leaders do show a lot of vulnerability. They really do show up with their full selves. They're not afraid to have difficult conversations. So I've seen some fantastic work happening there. We've been working with them on several different project streams, But most notably, one of their leadership onboarding programs. So we run 7 components of that for them, where we get leaders into a room to firstly reflect and think about who they are and what's important to themselves and what they want from work, and then start getting them to think about the people that they manage and how they might manage them more effectively. It's interesting, actually, on that program, we always get comments, things like, you know, I thought this program was going to make me a better manager, but it actually improved my relationship with my wife. You know, so it's always a nice feeling when you, when you sort of feel like you're, you're contributing to someone's own sense of satisfaction. So certainly, certainly they have been maybe more progressive than some other clients that I won't name and shame
[46:25] Leanne Elliott: We did ask if he'd name and shame and he refused
[46:27] Al Elliott: Quite right too. Quite right too
[47:01] Leanne Elliott: the HubSpot The audio destination for business professionals
[47:43] Al Elliott: It can
[47:51] Leanne Elliott: But come back
[47:52] Al Elliott: Yeah, come back. Definitely come back, because Nudge isn't as good as this, so come back. I'll cut that out. Keep that in. So what's number 7, Leanne?
