# Secondary-level interventions: raising awareness and training line managers

- **Episode:** [40](https://agents.truthliesandwork.com/episodes/40.md) (2023-05-24)
- **Type:** panel-interview
- **Tags:** training, line-managers, awareness, interventions
- **Time:** 33:40–55:25 (start 2020s)
- **Listen:** [https://truthliesandwork.com/40?t=2020](https://truthliesandwork.com/40?t=2020)

---

[33:40] Leanne Elliott: So as a leader, maybe take some time this week to reflect on your reason, your purpose, and also the reason you're giving to people so they want to come and work for you. They want to get out of bed in the morning. They want to contribute to mission delivery. And to paraphrase the greatest philosopher of our time, Sir RuPaul Charles, if you can't inspire yourself, how the hell are you going to inspire anyone else?
[34:01] Al Elliott: So if you're listening to this podcast, it's highly unlikely that you're completely closed off to the idea that wellbeing is good for business. You're going to be at least open-minded and more likely to be kind of a believer in the people and culture cause. But what happens if you don't have the seniority or the authority to put this kind of strategy in place? How, as people and culture or HR practitioners, are we going to secure the buy-in of the board and the senior members? Amy's advice is to arm yourself with the numbers. That's what they like
[34:28] Amy McEwan: So, I'm a great believer in, I've got a finite amount of energy and time on this planet, so let's use it on things that are actually going to have impact. But, actually, what I've found with those sorts of people is sometimes they can be your biggest champions, right? There are some that you're just never going to get there, so you can usually figure that out quite quickly. What I end up doing is creating the jigsaw and the structure around other things. A big part of what I have always done in what whatever role I've done is being able to speak different languages. So when I ran my mental health tech startup, I was— my father was a psychiatrist. It was taking his knowledge, right? That's how I got into this world. He specialized in stress, anxiety, depression in the, in like the '80s. So taking clinical language and tech language and business language and translating them into something that works. So that's where I think my skill set is, is being able to do that. So with those sorts of people, There's some that you're never gonna get on board. There are actually a lot of people that if you have the right conversation totally get it 'cause it's happened to them. Their wife's an alcoholic. Their daughter's had bulimia. You know, there's a lot of that. But also, when you've created your strategy and your aim and what you're trying to do, right, which is the bit that most people seem to forget, it's then about creating the narrative around that, right? And then selling that narrative. Most of health, mental health, and wellbeing is stakeholder management. So having a narrative which is, this is the right thing to do for productivity, for profitability, gets people on board. But also numbers, right? So when I work with organizations, one of the first things we look at is how much health and mental health is already costing them through absence, through people who are sick. I try to stick to things you can actually measure, not sort of waffly productivity type things, although people would argue you can measure that, but that's a whole other debate. When you look at what you're already spending, and then you say, well, this is not a strategic spend, we're an organization that actually prides itself on numbers. If we reallocate that strategic spend, rather than absence, we're putting it into decent health providers, it'll make us more profitable and more productive. And you quantify that, which you can. That gets some of the dinosaurs that aren't me, but the white male ones you're talking about, on board. So it's about having a number of different narratives up your sleeve, figuring out who you're talking to, and then turning it. And sometimes it can be— I went in to deal with a load of audit partners at Ernst Young. Now, audit partners, if you can imagine, they are the bean counters of the bean counters, right? So, very, very, you know, exactly as you've described, analytical people. And I went in with my slide pack, you know, thinking— because it's always hard when you're a sort of woman in your early— I was thinking I was late 20s, early 30s, trying to get on board those sorts of people. And they surprised me because, you know, I had my slides on numbers, and all they wanted to talk about was this being the right thing to do. But I've gone into other audiences that I thought would be soft and cuddly, and spent an hour justifying the numbers on slide 1. So it's just about being armed with knowing what you're doing, having the numbers, measuring it, being really clear what your strategic aims are and how you're going to measure it. But then figuring out different ways of selling it based on who you're dealing with
[37:34] Al Elliott: It's like anything you want to get buy-in on, just go with the numbers. Take yourself— take a PDF, like, Remember we said from, was it last week where we were talking about, or maybe the week before, we were saying that the way that Amazon does anything is they don't put together a project proposal, they put together a report of how it's going to look when it's finished. And then that's basically their objectives, their aims, their targets, everything. So just do that and go and get buying. It's the same as anything else
[37:58] Leanne Elliott: Yep. Some really great advice from, from Amy there. And hopefully—
[38:02] Al Elliott: And Al
[38:21] Al Elliott: We actually have a lot in common. We both use behavioral science to help people do better at work
[38:29] midroll (Phil Agnew, Nudge): And 2 out of 3 of us are devilishly good-looking
[38:46] Al Elliott: Seamless, seamless. Tell us about your latest episode, Phil
[39:09] Amy McEwan: It is
[39:24] midroll (Phil Agnew, Nudge): It can
[39:27] Michael: I am
[39:31] Leanne Elliott: But come back
[39:32] Al Elliott: Yeah, come back
[39:33] midroll (Phil Agnew, Nudge): Definitely come back because Nudge isn't as good as this, so come back
[39:35] Al Elliott: I'll cut that out
[39:37] midroll (Phil Agnew, Nudge): Keep that in
[39:38] Al Elliott: Leah, can you just talk us through the secondary level?
[39:44] Leanne Elliott: So basically, where primary-level interventions were about the organisation, secondary level is about the individual. So these types of interventions often help organisations to make significant improvements without all the upheaval of change that is needed for primary interventions, and they also have a more lasting preventative impact than tertiary interventions, which we'll talk about a bit more later
[40:06] Al Elliott: The first of these 3 steps is just really raising the awareness of it. I mean, this is the core of secondary level interventions because you want to make sure that a certain topic or issue is more visible within the community or the business or Um, you know, the group in which you're trying to get this implemented in. The goal is to make people understand the importance of a certain issue and then find the support to address it. Now, Mind, an incredible organization— if you're not from the UK, Mind is massive. It's like at the forefront of some of this stuff. It's been raising awareness for mental health for 70 years. Here's Andrew to explain a bit more
[40:39] Andrew: One of the services that most people will use at Mind is our Infoline. Uh, again, the Mind website has an A to Z, an introduction to common mental health problems, symptoms, treatments, where to go for support, our Side by Side online community, which is kind of peer-to-peer. There's a whole host of services, but we are a federated charity as well. So we have about 130 independent local Minds across the country. And again, many people will be familiar with their own local Mind, and they provide kind of local community services to really speak to the specific needs of some of our towns and some of our cities across the UK
[41:14] Al Elliott: But it's not just the services that Mind offers that's raising awareness. Their research has had huge impact at the highest of levels. We asked Andrew about the latest results from Mind's flagship Wellbeing Index
[41:26] Andrew: Absolutely. So again, just to give a bit of background to anyone who isn't aware of what our index is, our Workplace Wellbeing Index is our benchmark of best practice across the UK. It's been operating now for 7 years. We've had 384 different organizations participate. We've got a ridiculous number of data points, something along the lines of 45 million data points through individual questions. And each year we have about 50,000 employees answer various questions about mental health in the workplace. So every year following that kind of cycle of surveying and benchmarking best practice, we produce our Index Insights. And that really says year on year, what are the trends that we're seeing So the key statistic that I've been talking about today has been the fact that only 52% of employees who completed the Workplace Wellbeing Index would say that they feel supported by their organization. Now, that is a 6% decrease on last year. To some extent, we think that is related to a bit of wellbeing fatigue. And we also know that those employees have also said that they've seen a reduction in the amount of promotion from their organizations around employee mental health, around wellbeing. signposting to support services. So there's been an 11% reduction in the number of employees who have also said that they've seen that level of promotion. But that does mean that there's 48% of employees who do not currently feel supported in their business. So we know that's a significant number of employees
[42:49] Leanne Elliott: This is quite a sad-making statistic, isn't it? Half of employees in the UK don't feel supported by their organisation. Oh, it really just feels to me that organisations are maybe neglecting these secondary-level interventions that are better supporting people with either, you know, the stresses they have, the demands of their role, stress management, positive health promotion, better recruitment, and of course, as always, better management. As we'll hear from Andrew, line management is so important, and the data, the latest data, is backing this up
[43:24] Andrew: But another kind of important statistic that's come out of this year specifically has been looking at the significant impact that line managers play that level of support. So thinking about employees who say that they have supportive line managers, they're twice as likely to report good mental health outcomes compared to those that say that they don't have supportive line managers. And similarly, when looking at employees who say that they have effective working relationships with their line manager, they're 3 times more likely to report that they are happy at work than those that don't. So we know that line managers have a really important part to play in satisfaction at work, how productive they are at work, and their mental health outcomes at work. So that's been a lot of the narrative that we've really been talking about today, about how do we take those findings and recognize the importance of line management and translate that into some practical action. And if you're going to be accessing support, you're most likely to be accessing that support through your line manager. If you're having conversations about workplace or reasonable adjustments, that's most likely going to be through your line manager. And again, we We know that some of the challenges people have when they do have poor mental health is around competing tasks, competing challenges, knowing what to prioritise. And again, that workload prioritisation, a lot of that comes directly from a line manager
[44:35] Leanne Elliott: This is a really important aspect of secondary-level interventions, and the second that we want to highlight after raising awareness— training leaders. I feel like a broken record, so I'm going to hand it over to Amy as to why training leaders I mentor people across the industry
[44:55] Amy McEwan: I guess the main difference with that is I'm working with individuals who are in those sorts of roles as opposed to writing strategies. And they range from global wellbeing leads, but a lot of people are in SMEs or even running their own wellbeing businesses. And then what I realized while I was doing this mentoring work is that loads of people who are responsible for health, mental health, and wellbeing, to be blunt, are really passionate about it and have pivoted in from different like their D&I or their learning and development or their health and safety or their HR, and they've taken the health, mental health, wellbeing role. You know, sometimes in an SME it's a board member or a director of ops, but they don't really know what they're doing in terms of the wider health and mental health. So you end up with kind of health, safety, and wellbeing or diversity and inclusion with a bit of like mental health tacked on. So what I started to do is put together a practical training course. which was how to do health and mental health and wellbeing in a comprehensive way that works, and just run my first round. But as you said, like, quite a few people who came— I had some global wellbeing leads and people from big companies, but I also had a lot of people from SMEs. I had someone from a school. And what was great was, because you're running a course, everyone's sharing ideas, and you can transpose something that works very well in an SME to a large company, but also be creative about different environments and industries
[46:13] Al Elliott: So obviously, I think most of our guests believe that training line managers is crucial, but Andrew believes that to create this kind of business change, we need to level up the mental health literacy— what a phrase— of our leaders. Here's Andrew
[46:27] Andrew: Now, over the last decade, mental health literacy has certainly improved, particularly in workplace settings. But again, there is still a number of people in society who do not understand that we all have mental health just as we have physical health. They think of mental health problems on kind of a linear spectrum. So you're either mentally well or mentally unwell versus all of us having mental health, it being something that we all possess. But, you know, some of us will have enduring mental health problems and some of us will not, but all of us have wellbeing. And it's perfectly natural for that to fluctuate day to day or after any kind of event. I think, again, particularly amongst SMEs, a lot of managers just do not feel that they have the time to commit to having conversations about mental health or wellbeing, a large number of them might not feel that it's their responsibility. They might feel it's the responsibility of either the individual to kind of manage their own mental health and manage their own resilience, which would not be mine's position, or that it's the responsibility of HR or somebody that isn't them. And again, to them, we would say, you know, mental health and wellbeing and having that support available for your line reports is everyone's business. And it isn't just a moral thing to do, it's good business. Again, that's how you have happy, productive employees that deliver great results. And having a conversation with your line report about how they best perform at work is only to the benefit of your team and your outputs. But again, a large part of it does come down to having that time to have those discussions. If those line managers feel that they're under pressure, that they do not have time to stop and think, They're perhaps not going to be prioritizing the time that's needed to have a one-to-one conversation. And again, we know that to be effective in providing that support, you do need to have that one-to-one conversation with your line reporter. Trying to have a broad brush approach is not going to be particularly effective
[48:17] Al Elliott: So we're clearly putting a lot on these leaders and line managers. All of our expectations are rising, and of course we need to work to protect our own mental health and the mental health of our leadership peers and managers across the business. So I asked Andrew, what can we actually do to ensure that leaders and managers are also supported with their mental health?
[48:36] Andrew: So I think it's about having conversations with those line managers and making sure that as a starting point, everyone is on the same page about the importance and priority of mental health and wellbeing for themselves, for their teams, for the whole organisation. I think it's also about having conversation with those managers about what support they need support their people. Again, if you think about workplace adjustments, for example, you might be having team members come to you as a line manager asking for workplace adjustments. But if you're not sure of your organization's policy on the subject, if you're not sure what the organization deems reasonable or not reasonable, what budget's available, how you're able to effectively signpost to support that you might have internally, or how you signpost externally, Those are all barriers to that line manager feeling able to support, to be able to support themselves. So again, it's having that conversation with a manager about what can, you know, that senior leader, that business owner, what support can they provide their line managers that's going to make the process as simple as possible? And again, that's often a reason that employees themselves quote why they don't disclose that they have a mental health problem, because they don't have faith that anything's going to change as a result. And quite often for the line manager, that's because they don't know how to— they'll have the conversation, but they don't know how to then enact the change that's required. So just trying to have really strong communication and real clarity for what next steps look like for line managers is really important. But I'd also look to signpost employees and line managers and senior leaders, just everybody, to our wellness action plan template. So it's probably the most commonly given recommendation that we have in mind to businesses that we work with. But a wellness action plan is essentially, for line managers, a bit of a template on how to have a conversation with a line report. But it goes through what are the things that are sources of stress and sources of poor mental health for you? What supports you to have the best possible day at work? What supports you to thrive at work? When you're struggling, what does that look like? How does that manifest for you? Are there any signs that I should be looking for? Which, if you're working now in a hybrid environment, actually having that plan and having your employee tell you explicitly what that looks like is really important, because it might be harder to kind of pick out some of those elements or changes in behavior if you're only looking at someone through a screen. And then what do you want them to do? So if they do spot some of those signs, do you want them to say something? Do you want them to send an email? Would you prefer that they— message someone in your household or a family member, what do you as an employee want those next steps to look like? So again, it's really helpful for line managers to facilitate a conversation with their line reports. And if you feel that you don't have a particularly supportive manager as an employee, it can be a really helpful reflective exercise in and of itself. But also it does give you a kind of entry point to having that conversation with your line, your line manager. Because you've already done the hard work of thinking about the questions, reflecting on them, putting them down on paper, and saying, this is how I think I could be a more productive employee. And positioning that with your line manager is a very difficult conversation to not listen to. And again, it gives it a real obvious structure for a line manager to be able to take away, read, and fully comprehend and understand
[51:51] Leanne Elliott: Just to pick up on a couple of things that Andrew said there, I think helping line managers signpost is really important. Just create a one-page document, you know, based on the challenges that people are experiencing and have a service that managers can signpost employees to if they need to. It's not fair to put our line managers in these situations where, you know, a vulnerable employee comes to them and they don't know what to do or can't do anything about it. And I think as a second part to that as well, it's training line managers to have these difficult conversations, to not freak out if an employee comes to them and says, I'm not doing so great. Our instinct is to fix things, particularly line managers. We just want to fix things, we want to make it better. And as we talked so much before, often it's just creating a space for somebody to be heard, to talk about what they're experiencing, and just listen. But of course, again, line managers need this training and need this development to help them do that effectively. If you are looking at line manager training please do get in touch. Uh, we have— again, we can signpost you to some great providers and talk to you about the, the type of line manager training you want that's going to have the most impact in your business. The final aspect of secondary-level interventions that we want to highlight is earlier interventions. So secondary-level, along with primary-level interventions, are a really important opportunity to prevent mental health challenges from escalating. It really is about prevention of a cure. Mental health is common. 1 in 6 of us will experience a mental health disorder in our lifetime. That's more than diabetes, which is 1 in 11, heart attacks, that is 1 in 8, Alzheimer's, which is 1 in 9. It's the same as a stroke, 1 in 6. Prevention is a powerful approach in the workforce, and many providers are championing this, including Cooth Work. Let's hear from Michael
[53:39] Michael: So I think really where we need to be looking at as a whole, everybody who's at the water cooler event, and everybody like myself, my colleagues at Cooth Work, and the wellbeing leaders we work with, somehow we need to try and put in some early interventions in there. Because we can all try and provide fixes at the end. You know, there's great support through EAPs and, um, There's some great resources out there to help people who are actually going through a mental health crisis and that kind of cure side. But I think where we need to really focus our energy now is on prevention and early intervention. You know, this is a personal opinion of mine, but I always think that mental health is mental health safety because if you're dealing with construction industries or emergency services like we do, you've got— there's a heavy emphasis on prevention. You talk to someone from the fire services, right? They learned a long time ago about the best way of preventing a fire, or the best way of tackling a fire is that the fire doesn't exist in the first place. So fire services spend enormous amounts of their resources and time preventing fires, educating the public, changing culture and understanding. And that's exactly the same approach that we should be taking with mental health. The best way to prevent mental health decline, or the best way to deal with mental health decline, is to prevent it happening in the first place
