# Pillar 3 — Empathy-based management

- **Episode:** [54](https://agents.truthliesandwork.com/episodes/54.md) (2023-08-31)
- **Type:** panel-interview
- **Tags:** empathy, management, flexible-work
- **Time:** 41:33–61:28 (start 2493s)
- **Listen:** [https://truthliesandwork.com/54?t=2493](https://truthliesandwork.com/54?t=2493)

---

[41:33] Al Elliott: So before we go on to number 3, can you just sum up for us flexible work experiences, Leigh?
[41:39] Leanne Elliott: Yeah, I think flexible work experience is about creating that flexibility responsibility for our people to help them build resilience to change. Change is, is going to stay with us. So I think it really is about creating environments in which people feel able, resilient, and agile to the, the changes that are inevitably going to come up, whether within our control as a growth organization or whether it be external factors. The second, I think, leadership being open to change and also change within the organization as you grow Your culture, your organisation will change, your role within it will change too. It's being open to that and embracing that. And I think finally doing those 2 things is gonna help build positive relationships within your organisation. And as we know, they are the key to psychological safety, which in turn is the key to creativity and collaboration
[42:28] Al Elliott: Fabulous. So that was foundation number 2. Foundation number 3 is empathy-based management. Leigh, what do we need to know about this?
[42:36] Leanne Elliott: Well, a strong trait in people who are empathetic and compassionate is emotional intelligence. It helps us be a better leader, it helps to be a better team player, and all in all, being honest, just a better person. Empathy-based management is something that is talked about more and more frequently, and I think that the key for me— there's different elements of empathy. I think the key for me, and the one that seems to resonate most with the people that may be a bit more skeptic or think this is a bit fluffy and soft to be empathetic as a leader is empathic concern. What can I do as a leader to make your job easier and make you more productive? The importance of creating workplaces that prioritize this type of empathy will breed human connection, and that emotional intelligence is also going to be what underpins authentic relationships. All 3 of our speakers shared this view that empathy is fundamental when it comes to effective management in today's organisations. Mel emphasised that relationship building and a mission-driven culture, while Stacy focused on emotional management. Catherine stressed the importance of power skills and the acknowledgement of emotions at work. Here's Catherine
[43:56] Catherine de la Poer: And I'm particularly interested in emotional intelligence. Because for me, I think that's the secret sauce of great leadership. And it is also, it's how we make workplaces more human. So it's what a lot of people call the soft skills, what I like to call human skills or power skills. So yeah, I work with organizations to help people to really understand, um, the impact of bringing emotion and feeling back to work. Because when I started 30 years ago, emotions weren't really wanted at work. In fact, it was almost like, leave your emotions at the door, they're not required here
[44:42] Leanne Elliott: Did you know that the UK's number 1 management podcast— that's us, by the way— and the UK's number 1 marketing We actually have a lot in common
[44:53] Al Elliott: We both use behavioral science to help people do better at work
[44:59] midroll (Phil Agnew, Nudge): And 2 out of 3 of us are devilishly good-looking
[45:16] Al Elliott: Seamless, seamless. Tell us about your latest episode, Phil
[45:39] Al Elliott: It is
[45:54] midroll (Phil Agnew, Nudge): It can
[45:57] midroll (Phil Agnew, Nudge): I am
[46:02] Leanne Elliott: But come back
[46:03] Al Elliott: Yeah, come back
[46:03] midroll (Phil Agnew, Nudge): Definitely come back because Nudge isn't as good as this. So come back
[46:07] Al Elliott: I'll cut that out
[46:08] midroll (Phil Agnew, Nudge): Keep that in
[46:12] Leanne Elliott: Yeah
[46:13] Al Elliott: Just before we go on to Mel to talk about emotional intelligence, I heard what might be the worst example of the difference between empathy and sympathy the other day on Twitter. Leanne's example of the difference between empathy and sympathy is if someone's stuck in a hole, a big hole, then sympathy is standing at the top of the hole and going, oh, that looks horrible. I hope you're okay. Empathy is getting a ladder, getting down into the hole and going, oh, it's dark down here, isn't it? This guy on Twitter was saying, oh, the difference between empathy and sympathy is imagine you're standing on the edge of a ship and someone's throwing up. Sympathy is standing next to them and giving them a sick bag and saying, are you okay? Empathy is throwing up with them. I thought that was a very strange analogy
[46:52] Leanne Elliott: I'm not sure that's it
[46:53] Al Elliott: I don't think it is either
[46:56] Leanne Elliott: I think it's a good effort. I admire it. The, the, the try
[47:00] Al Elliott: Good try. C minus. So Mel talks about emotional intelligence quite a lot. Now, she said it's sometimes difficult to listen without judgment, and I think all of us struggle with this. But Mel, who seems to have nailed this emotional intelligence, um, has a great way to listen without judgment
[47:17] Mel Murphy: I, I practice something called unlimited positive regard. So I will come into every situation and For anyone who studied Mental Health First Aid, this is a key concept of that, um, is not having judgment in any situation. So just being completely open. And even if someone is coming at you and going, this is awful, I hate this, you are just a recipient of that. You're hearing it. That's their perspective. That's their lived experience. You have no place to judge in that space. Hear them out and therefore create that, that safety for them so that they continue— can continue to communicate in that way
[47:57] Leanne Elliott: I think as humans, it's almost impossible for us not to be judgmental in, in some way. You know, we're gonna have an opinion on what somebody is thinking or saying or experiencing. I think it's more a case of be judgmental, just shut the fuck up about it. Like, you know, if I'm gonna listen to you and be empathetic and, and try and, try and help you in this situation, you don't need my opinion. I can have it, and I can maybe go back to them, you know, back home to my partner and go, you won't believe what Jeff said today, you know. But I don't— I just don't think— I just, you know
[48:31] Al Elliott: So regular listeners will know that Leanne and I used to volunteer for a charity called the Samaritans in the UK. The whole point of that is non-judgmental listening, but it is so difficult to listen to someone and put your judgment to one side, particularly when it's something which you've been in, been through yourself
[48:45] Leanne Elliott: It can be. And I think, again, this is why, you know, as a manager, if there's one skill that you're going to develop, it's that listening skills. And I think really, you know, coaching is a brilliant way to— in terms of training, you know, training in some kind of coach-based leadership is really effective because it teaches you all these skills. It's not about changing your opinion. It's not about changing how you think things should operate or work. It's about learning that your opinion in this moment is not It's not important, and it's not going to be helpful. Lovely
[49:17] Al Elliott: Lovely. We should get a t-shirt with that on
[49:18] Leanne Elliott: Your opinion is not helpful
[49:21] Al Elliott: We don't care. No, we do care about your opinion
[49:24] Leanne Elliott: Oh, it is though, all right? That's why we've got podcasts
[49:25] Al Elliott: Yeah, if you've got a microphone, you're allowed an opinion
[49:30] Stacy: So
[49:30] Leanne Elliott: Do you have a microphone?
[49:31] Al Elliott: Yeah, maybe that's not a good judgement. We have listened to some podcasts where they perhaps shouldn't have microphones. Anyway, so—
[49:39] Leanne Elliott: Ooh, shade who?
[49:41] Al Elliott: I'm not gonna say anything
[49:42] Leanne Elliott: Ugly one who?
[49:42] Al Elliott: No, no, no, no, no, no. I'm not saying because the whole point is that, is that—
[49:46] Leanne Elliott: No judgement
[49:46] Al Elliott: No judgement. Although there's plenty of judgement here. So if your workplace feels like it's squeezing every single drop of work from you, then it just feels like you are surviving, not thriving. Now, Katherine talks about this compassionate environment, which helps people to thrive instead
[50:03] Catherine de la Poer: Increasingly, organisations are starting to realise that if you want to have people thriving. You know, there's a scale here, isn't there, between people who are surviving and then what we really want with engagement is we want people who are actually thriving, who are leaning into work, where we're getting more than just a 9 to 5 out of them. So I think there's huge bodies of research now that evidence the importance of the investment in whole human being if you want to have a productive, um, high-performing workforce
[50:43] Al Elliott: The perfect example of this is the idea that leaders or management or senior management seem to think that everyone should be at work and doing 8 hours of focused nonstop work. We can't do that. We all know that 8 hours of focused work is impossible, like with anything. Especially work
[51:00] Catherine de la Poer: There is a recognition of what does it mean to be human? Well, I think one of the things about being human is being on your A-game and doing 100% focused work for 8 hours a day is just nonsense. It's just not true. So then what is emerging from all of the neuroscience now about being in the flow of work, Because best guess what? That's when we do our best thinking. That's when we do our innovating. And going back to this idea of, you know, if you're an investor, you've got Company A, you've got Company B, where do you put your money? Do you know what? I want to put my money into that healthy workforce. I wanna put my money where people want to go to work, where there are low indicators of burnout, where there are, you know, where people are actually socialising at work. They're doing focused work for some of the day, but they're also doing collaborative working, because guess what? That's what humans like to do best. We're kind of made for that collaboration, social piece, where there's also— you're building rest and recovery into the working day
[52:12] Leanne Elliott: Stacy made a really awesome observation. She feels that the pandemic has forced us all to be a little more kind to each other and to ourselves
[52:22] Stacy: And I actually think the pandemic enabled us to connect with people in a way we've not been able to do in a long while, and also able us to soothe ourselves without the distractions that we often have to pay for, because those things weren't available to us. So we had to think outside of the box, um, and I think also enabled us to I guess, appreciate somewhat the finer things in life. It kind of calmed that dopamine aspect of us and actually allowed a lot more of the serotonin, longer-term happiness, oxytocin-type activity, which is caring for each other, hanging out with like one another when we can, communicating, all of that stuff. So I think coming out of the pandemic, it just reinforced my values, you know, about kind— how much kindness is important, how much friendship is important, how much connection is important. You know, yes, achievement, success, you know, doing well in life. Yeah, it, it can help you along those ways. But if you don't have the fundamental basics, then inevitably you will feel the wrath of the human condition. You will feel disappointed and sad and ashamed and guilty
[53:32] Leanne Elliott: And Katherine completely agrees
[53:34] Catherine de la Poer: That kindness is the, is the highest form of intelligence. I'm very fortunate to be married to a man who's incredibly kind. And it's something that, it's a value and a trait that I really respect in other people. And I think that is the beginning of change, being kind to yourself, being compassionate to yourself, as we talked about earlier, forgiving self. And I think that has gotta be the beginning of of a massive transformational change. All change has to start with, with self. If you're gonna go on some kind of transformation journey, organizational wellbeing journey, it starts with myself. What is, what is the world I want to create?
[54:25] Al Elliott: Okay, so we know that compassion means kindness, but what happens when you have to have a difficult conversation with someone? As most leaders at some point in their career will have to do. Well, can you still be compassionate? Mel from Birdie explains that she thinks you can
[54:40] Mel Murphy: So I went over this concept that, um, there are 3 types of conversation. All, all conversations fall into one of 3 types. They are relationship building, possibility building, or moving towards action. And I see them as like a, a child stacking toy, you know, the one with the, the stick and 3 donuts on it. And the key for me is that foundational element, which is building a relationship, understanding your peers, understanding your direct reports, understanding your manager in a way that embraces them as their whole self, not just the person that they turn up to work as. So, are we asking the right questions? Are we listening? Are we hearing, which are 2 different things? And are we really understanding who this person is? is, are we creating space for them to be able to say, actually, I'm not aligned with this project, this is my flag, I think this is a blocker? You know, are we creating those spaces? Because if we aren't, what we're doing is we're driving, driving people to deliver on things that they, they don't feel psychologically safe working on. And so build that relationship first, allow people to show up as their whole selves, and then when you have those tough conversations, they're a lot easier to have because you're you're, you're coming at it from a place of mutual trust
[55:53] Al Elliott: So being kind to yourself is so, so important. I think often comparing yourself to others is the worst thing you can do. It was Teddy Roosevelt who said that comparison is the thief of joy. Why would you count someone else's blessings instead of your own?
[56:10] Stacy: Like, I, I remember working for a crisis team over in West London, which is attached to Imperial College, right? Genius college for mathematicians, scientists and you'd have people that had been top of the tree in their secondary school, done really well. And then suddenly they were surrounded by other geniuses and no longer were they at the top of the tree. They were like 25 in their class and they literally could not handle— to them, they were then a failure. They could not see the bigger picture. They could not take a helicopter view and compare themselves to any other student within the UK. They compared themselves to that year group, and they would rather have a, a diagnosed mental illness, so there was a reason for them becoming 25, or they'd rather die. And I find that absolutely shocking that a person would rather not be on this planet rather than not get an A. And that's how much kind of pressure is put on our younger kids nowadays
[57:11] Leanne Elliott: So, this idea of kindness might sound, I don't know, lefty, woke, wishy-washy, fluffy, some may say. Maybe it's just for those organisations that plant trees, that have mindfulness at lunch, some kind of vegan menu in the cafeteria, Al
[57:29] Al Elliott: Oat milk Frappuccinos
[57:32] Leanne Elliott: I do enjoy an oat milk Frappuccino, actually
[57:35] Al Elliott: You've changed, man
[57:37] Leanne Elliott: But anyway, no, kindness isn't woke. Kindness is good for business. Kindness is good for performance. Even the F1 teams that Stacy works with embrace kindness
[57:49] Stacy: When you're working for a high-performance team, like the, the trials and tribulations, and also like what you give, like life-wise, like a lot of those guys are like away every single week. They, their sleep patterns all over the place, and like the highs and the lows of the win is like difficult. And I think it's the same with if you think about like other type of performers, musicians, you know. And there's also not just the drivers but the whole team around them that sacrifice their life, go away from their families. And, you know, so I think the Formula 1 team that I work with are very forward-thinking about supporting their staff and also want to be making sure that, you know, if People are struggling, that they're able to come out and speak out and get the support that they need. Right?
[58:35] Al Elliott: So kindness to yourself is so important, and it can include challenging our own assumptions about ourselves and our circumstances. Leanne taught me this idea of cognitive thinking error, and it's really common when you're feeling stressed or overwhelmed or unsure about the future. You may have heard it called irrational thinking or irrational beliefs. And whilst they're irrational, they're definitely not uncommon
[59:00] Leanne Elliott: They're not uncommon, and I think this is why psychoeducation is really important. By understanding ourselves and us, our own thoughts as humans, how our mind works, will help us be kind to ourselves and over time be kind to others. There are many, many different types of thinking errors. Um, there may be some that more common. And I think if we can start to identify these types of thinking errors in ourselves and in our teams, that will really start to help us be more effective and empathic as managers. So to name a few that you might see pop up or observe in either yourself or others more frequently: mind reading or jumping to conclusions, particularly conclusions that we don't have control over. For example, if I don't work overtime, then I'll get sacked. That is an example, an example of mind reading. Another one is all-or-nothing thinking, or thinking in extremes. So things like, uh, my job is awful, this, um, this situation is terrible, uh, this customer is the worst, this always happens to me. That's all-or-nothing thinking. Labeling is another type thinking error that can be very detrimental to our self-esteem, to our self-efficacy. This is where we basically call ourselves names. We'll say, I'm an idiot, I'm stupid, um, you know, why would anybody, you know, want to be around me because I'm such an idiot? That's the type of labeling of ourselves that is, is, as I said, is really destructive. That's probably one as well you'll find coming up within your teams as well if they are struggling with stress. Um, they'll start to label themselves in this way. And the final one that is quite common, phonyism. This will probably sound familiar. It's where you'll say things like, you know, if I, if I perform badly, people will see the real me. They'll know that I'm a fraud. That is essentially imposter syndrome, and phonyism is a thinking error that sits behind imposter syndrome. So there are some common thinking errors. There are many others. I would absolutely suggest that you try to start to identify these in your own way of thinking and with those in your teams. And to help with that, Al, I thought we would finish this episode with a little suggested exercise, a little challenge for our listeners to maybe start to help them identify these thinking errors. What do you think?
