# The Elon Musk debate: what should we admire in leaders?

- **Episode:** [87](https://agents.truthliesandwork.com/episodes/87.md) (2024-04-04)
- **Type:** interview
- **Tags:** elon-musk, leadership, admiration
- **Time:** 39:43–44:41 (start 2383s)
- **Listen:** [https://truthliesandwork.com/87?t=2383](https://truthliesandwork.com/87?t=2383)

---

[39:43] Al Elliott: Before you go though, I had one more question for Dave, and this is a recurring theme, I think, on the pod. But I had to ask him, does he think Elon Musk is a good leader?
[39:53] Dave Kline: I generally don't know, is the, is the answer. I, but I put it in 3 buckets. Do I admire the outcomes that he has been able to produce in multiple domains? Absolutely. And I think that puts him in an exceptionally elite class of entrepreneur. There just aren't that many who get to scale and success of true innovation. Not once, but twice, but 3 times, but 4 times, but 5 times. Like, it's a very small list. And so he must be doing something right. I, like, humbly submit to that. I also— so bucket 2, I also think that we are going through probably the most meaningful evolution of business management in a decade, or sorry, in a decade, in a century
[40:41] midroll (Phil Agnew, Nudge): Yeah
[40:42] Dave Kline: You know, like, there was the Industrial Revolution, all of that. But I think the introduction of AI, of automation, of remote work. Like all these things I think are going to be reassembled into a new way of working, like gig work. There's just so many different components that are moving. And my hunch without any insight, I don't, other than having a couple students in our program from Tesla, I don't have any like real window in there. My hunch is like he's starting to reassemble those pieces in ways that are differentiated and may inform sort of the next operating system norm. That comes up. And then the third, where I would just say, like, I don't know, but like the caricature that he paints of himself online, it reminds me a little bit of like the caricature that Ray becomes in public. We had another student from Apple, and sort of she described the caricature that Steve Jobs became, that there was a difference between how the public perceived them and how the people within the walls admired them. And so my hunch is probably he's a pretty good leader. It would be hard to sort of stack all those pieces together and say no. But I also bet that he's magnetic in the way that there's certain people who would be deeply drawn to both his missions and his style, and a probably much larger group of people who would be violently repelled by how he approaches things. And the same was true of Ray, and the same was true of Steve Jobs and, and others
[42:13] Leanne Elliott: I think we could probably do an entire episode on Elon Musk and his— the questionable ethics behind his leadership and management practices. It does come down to, I guess, can you separate the work from the individual? And in terms of organisational life, I find that very, very, very difficult. But we will see how, how history favours him in the end
[42:33] Al Elliott: Yeah, he definitely seems to be a little bit more of the Steve Jobs school of leading than perhaps Someone else. But it's just interesting because he's just everywhere, and so you can't have a conversation about leadership or management without speaking about him or the other T-word, which we're not going to bring up. Anyway, if you enjoyed this—
[42:50] Leanne Elliott: I see now why you're not as comfortable to talk about the T-word. Because of the innovation? Because of what it's contributing to society? Does that make it ethically better because it's part of a bigger cause? Arguably, supporters of Trump could say the same about him
[43:02] Al Elliott: That's a fair point, actually. Thinking about it, that's a fair point because the reason why I don't laud the way that Steve, uh, Steve Jobs did or managed people, but I do feel that the world was left in a much better place, um, with him in it. Um, and I suppose there are some people who say that he's not. So yeah, good point. Good point. I do think that overall Musk is net positive for the world. Um, it's just some of the way he does things don't seem to be the more traditional route if, uh, Another discussion to pick up another day, I think. Definitely. If you enjoyed this sort of, this banter or discussion, then you're probably gonna like our Tuesday show where we round up the latest news in the world of work. We have a little chat, we bring the experts of tomorrow, and Leanne holds the workplace surgery where she answers all your work culture questions
[43:50] Leanne Elliott: Yes, if you have a question, then email us. What have we had on recently? We've had questions around toxic bosses, about some dodgy interview practices, We've had questions around, is it okay for my member of staff to be drunk and, and call me up at the weekend, tell me to fuck myself?
[44:04] Al Elliott: Um, that's true
[44:06] Leanne Elliott: We do
[44:06] midroll (Phil Agnew, Nudge): Yeah
[44:07] Leanne Elliott: So if you've got anything along those lines or indeed something new, send it in
[44:11] Al Elliott: Yeah, we definitely will. We can either read it out if you do a voice note, we'll read it out, or if you email it, we'll keep it anonymous if that's what you want. Okay. Anything else to add, my love?
[44:19] midroll (Phil Agnew, Nudge): No
[44:20] Al Elliott: Okay. Well, bye for now
[44:22] Leanne Elliott: Bye
[44:22] Al Elliott: Bye-bye
[44:31] Leanne Elliott: Right, the work, whether it be art or business, from the individual. It's, um, anyway, maybe cut that out now because I'm not entirely sure that, uh, Elon Musk won't come for me for that
