# The Peter Principle — and why it's unfair to blame the promoted

- **Episode:** [87](https://agents.truthliesandwork.com/episodes/87.md) (2024-04-04)
- **Type:** interview
- **Tags:** peter-principle, promotion, management
- **Time:** 13:55–16:25 (start 835s)
- **Listen:** [https://truthliesandwork.com/87?t=835](https://truthliesandwork.com/87?t=835)

---

[13:55] Al Elliott: There's an old saying, probably more from the '80s than it is actually from now, that you get promoted to the level of your incompetence. In other words, if you're good at sales, then your next stop is probably going to be sales manager. But being an exceptional manager is very different to being an exceptional individual contributor
[14:12] Dave Kline: It's the Peter Principle, but I think it is unfair to strictly lay that at the feet of the people being promoted into those positions. Like, if you sort of play out the typical lifecycle, we stare at a function, we pick our absolute best salesperson, software engineer, A-player. So this person has been wildly successful. That's why we're thinking, oh, wouldn't it be great if they could sprinkle some of their success fairy dust on the rest of the team? And we make them a manager. And a lot of times we think of that promotion as the destination. When in reality, it's actually the beginning of an entirely new occupation, right? Like, when you are an individual contributor, it's all about, do I have the answers? Can I build up mastery of a specific concept? Can I deliver and hit deadlines? When you become a first-time manager, now it's, can I have more impact through other people? Can I prioritize what matters and what doesn't so my team focuses on the right things? Can I delegate? Can I evaluate work? Can I give feedback? That allows them to succeed. And that's just a very different set of capabilities. And when companies just think of that as the destination, I sort of call that management by hazing or leadership development by hazing. It's like, well, I figured it out because you're one of the people, probably the person promoting you is one of the people who are on the right side of that 60% number and they figured it out. And so why shouldn't you? When in reality, There's just a handful of fundamental concepts that you could gift these new managers on day 1 that would massively increase their odds
[15:49] Leanne Elliott: This leads to a lot of managers being replaced quickly
[15:53] Dave Kline: There were studies by Gartner, Korn Ferry, Harvard, McKinsey. They've looked at entry-level managers, mid-level managers, C-suite. They've looked across geographies, and plus or minus, call it 50 to 60% of managers fail and get replaced within 18 to 24 months. Which is an outrageously bad set of odds, right? Imagine flipping a coin and saying, it's probably gonna land on the wrong side in terms of you succeeding over the next 18 months. And for those of you who do succeed, we'll probably promote you and flip the coin again
